7 Best PLL Fan Theories! (2024)

During last week's 100th episode of Pretty Little Liars, the name of the girl buried in Alison's grave was finally revealed—Bethany Young, a patient at Radley who escaped the same night that Ali disappeared. For about two seconds, we felt relieved to have that mystery solved, but then we we were faced with the next burning question: "Who's Bethany Young?!?"

While last night's episode didn't offer too many clues, lucky for us, five seasons of "A" has turned PLL fans into pretty good detectives. Check out the best #BethanyYoung Twitter theories—then tell us yours!

Alison's twin

Mr. Hastings' daughter with Mrs. DiLaurentis

"A"

The girl Jason saw with Melissa that night

Toby's mom's killer!

Someone who knew too much...

Jason's Twin?!

When it comes to PLL the possibilities are endless...

These PLL fans think they know who #BethanyYoung is—do you?? Share your theories in the comments below!

MORE:

7 Times Hanna Was The Best Thing That Ever Happened On Pretty Little Liars

Lucy Hale Answers All Your Burning PLL Questions—Including The Truth About Her Relationship With Ian!

The Ultimate PLL Trivia Quiz