spotlight
Our round-up of letters published in the Ravalli Republic
1
Letter to the editor: National Stuttering Awareness Week
May 12-18 is National Stuttering Awareness Week. One in every 100 people stutter. That’s 80 million people worldwide! Yet stuttering is often misunderstood and even laughed at.
To address the many myths surrounding this complex disorder, the Stuttering Foundation has compiled a list of “75 Must-Use Resources for the Stuttering Community” — available free on our website: StutteringHelp.org.
The Foundation’s most popular content represents a mix of time-tested favorites and newer innovations:
- Drawings and Letters from Kids webpagefeaturing submissions from children around the world and published in our magazine.
- Answers for Employers brochureanswering frequent questions from employers received by the Foundation each year.
- Self-Therapy for the Stutterer e-bookwritten by Founder Malcolm Fraser in 1978.
- List of Famous People Who Stutter webpagecontinuously updated with many celebrities, sports heroes, writers and world leaders.
- Podcast webpagenow in its sixth season with more than 100,000 listeners.
- Advice to Those Who Stutter audio bookdrafted in 1972 and updated by 28 therapists who stutter themselves.
- I Stutter ID Card webpagehelping people identify themselves in a nonverbal way.
Jane Fraser, president,
The Stuttering Foundation
2
Letter to the editor: Vote in the primary to be represented
Everyone in Ravalli County knows that practically all our elected officials are not only Republican, but increasingly extreme right-wing Republicans. We also know that since it’s very difficult for a Democrat to win the general election, whoever wins the Republican primary will be our representative or senator. The strategy that the extreme segment of the Ravalli County Republican Party uses to help their candidate win is to make sure there are multiple candidates in the primary to split the vote among more moderate candidates.
This is the case in the Senate District 44 race. There is a Democrat on the ballot, but no Democrat in the valley recognizes him or knows what he stands for. Similarly, Brad Davis, a Republican, says he wants to be a legislator to make sure his trapping hobby is protected by amending the Constitution (a right that is already assured in our State Constitution, by the way). But he is just attempting to take votes from Wayne Rusk. Having a third Republican and a phony Democrat in the primary is a desperate move on Manzella’s part to split the vote because, in my opinion, she can’t win on her merits (if she has any).
Republicans continually remind everyone that we don’t have a Democracy, but that we have a Representative Republic. If you want to be fairly represented, study and evaluate the candidates and vote accordingly. How well you are represented in Helena depends on it.
Margaret Gorski,
Stevensville
3
Letter to the editor: Rusk will make Bitterrooters proud
In recent days, Wayne Rusk, a committed conservative candidate for State Senator SD44 seat, has faced a negative mailer campaign funded by a supporter of his opponent, Theresa Manzella. The man behind the mailer, Bob Kubiak, has targeted not only Rusk and the citizens of Victor, but also Rusk's children and their friends, by mailing the flyer that he cut and pasted about Rusk's past life to them embarrassing the children over events that happened more than 10 years ago. Kubiak displayed a despicable lack of decency by targeting children who can do nothing about man's vile behavior. It seems that Kubiak is a member of the John Birch contingency who are overstepping boundaries of decent behavior in this valley. Join me in voting for RUSK for SD44, who will protect children and not allow them to be targeted for political purposes. Rusk will protect the kids and the citizens of the valley, and write superb legislation to help keep them safe and secure in their home and communities, and most important, he will make Bitterrooters proud they elected him. Rusk has committed his life to the Heavenly Father that has blessed him and he will not fail in passing the blessings to the community by being the best legislator they could ever hope for.
Helen Sabin,
Corvallis
4
Letter to the editor: Continuing support for Wayne Rusk
Two years ago, I felt the need to write a letter in support of Wayne Rusk in his bid for the House District 88 seat. I was completely convinced of Wayne’s ability to serve our community in the state legislature, and having watched closely during this last session, I was not disappointed. Wayne proved himself to be that level-headed man I touted him to be. He measured his words; he thought before he spoke; and his actions proved him to be the deep man of conviction I know him to be. Wayne’s patriotism, his care and concern for his community and his state, and his understanding of our history and foundations came fully to the forefront. He is approachable and open to hear other opinions, and then make the hard decisions on his own based on careful research.
It disappoints me that Wayne and his family find him under attack again, with the same tired, outdated allegations we heard two years ago. While I am confident that citizens in Ravalli County, specifically in Senate District 44, will not be duped by this type of politics, I once again wish to voice my wholehearted support of Wayne in the upcoming primary election.
Please vote for Wayne Rusk in Senate District 44.
Chris Hoffman, Ravalli County Sheriff (ret.),
Former Ravalli County Commissioner
5
Letter to the editor: Voice your concerns about our overheating climate
Montana is feeling the effects of climate change first-hand: heatwaves, droughts, dwindling snowpacks, wildfires and floods. The severity of wildfire smoke prompts people to leave the state for the summer.
In June, Montana Citizens’ Climate Lobby volunteers are headed to D.C. to meet Senators Daines and Tester and Representatives Zinke and Rosendale. Their mission? To advocate for proactive climate bills to avoid the worst of climate change, and protect us from harm.
Key legislation includes the Energy Innovation Act, Increased Technical Service Providers Access Act, the BIG WIRES Act, and the Prove It Act.
Combined, these bills reduce government spending, protect our health, and cut our carbon pollution 50% by 2030 in the most cost-effective way. They help accelerate transmission line permitting and construction, and pave the way for clean, reliable domestic energy. They encourage other countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions like the carbon dioxide that is produced by burning fossil fuels.
You can help.
Contact our members of Congress and voice your concerns about our overheating climate. Ask them to enact market-based climate policies. They only respond to us if they hear from us.
Endorse these policies! See https://citizensclimatelobby.org/our-climate-solutions/endorse/.
Serious about fighting climate change and want to volunteer? Join us! CCL is a nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy climate change organization focused on national climate policies.
We all breathe the same air and need a safe place to live, reliable water sources, food security, and a stable climate. Together, we can all win and protect our communities now and for the future.
Alexandra Amonette,
Big Timber
6
Letter to the editor: Ethics matter; vote for Wayne Rusk
The character qualifications couldn’t be more opposite than the choice between Wayne Rusk and Manzella. Wayne Rusk earned a record of integrity while serving in the state House of Representatives last session, while Manzella’s record was less than stellar and at the least, self serving. These two candidates couldn’t be more opposite. Last campaign season Manzella used Wayne’s donor list and contacted the donors using her official Senate stationery without the permission of Rusk. She advised Rusk’s donors that they shouldn’t vote for Rusk but vote for her. On state stationery! A law was passed in the 2023 legislature to prevent this occurring again.
The positive side of ethical behavior is now being shown in the recent ads of endorsem*nt in support of Wayne by the legislators from Ravalli County who have served in the past 30 years plus current and past Ravalli County officials. This is powerful recognition plus endorsem*nt by the folks that know from their own experience what it takes to accomplish good public service and the excellent operation of Ravalli County and the state government. Ethics matter… endorsem*nts matter…character counts!
You won’t be disappointed if you elect Wayne Rusk for Senate District 44.
Ed Greef and Ray Hawk
Past Representatives HD88, HD90
Florence
7
Letter to the editor: Disappointed in Republican leaders
I am unhappy with Montana’s elected Republicans and how their majority recklessly drives the state into one ditch and then another. Weekly reports highlighting improprieties stemming from the governor’s office, to the attorney general, to the Office of Public Instruction, to the Public Service Commission, are intolerable.
As leaders, they gave us higher property taxes and fewer dollars for schools. They managed to oversee cuts in Medicaid funding and watched seniors being thrown out of closing facilities. Knudsen’s office shamelessly attacks the courts for protecting Montanans from suffering under unconstitutional laws approved by Don Kaltschmidt. Superintendent Elsie Arntzen leads her own war against public schools. And, not surprising, culture wars are her bag, public education never was.
When I remember watching the majority use its time drafting unconstitutional bills in an attempt to legislatively re-engineer our social, environmental and economic landscapes to match its hom*ophobic, poacher-friendly, tax dodging, collective ethos; I fear I’ll wake up one day surrounded by hillbillies and being forced to attend nationally televised Trump Bible Study sessions before being sent to work in a Bozeman sweatshop cranking out guns and traps.
I want a responsible government. I want elected representatives who perform their service with respect for those they serve. I do not want to live under an oppressive and paranoid, dogmatic regime that takes its marching orders from an unscrupulous, grifter.
The GOP is dead. In its place rises the spawn of a side-show barker, pretentious, dull, and selfish. One by one, I shall vote them out.
Jeff Meide,
Billings
8
Letter to the editor: Microplastics in everything
- Mary Fahnestock-Thomas, Hamilton
Today I heard a new friend telling another new friend that there is a law “coming down the pike” that will take all control of our children’s health away from us.
I don’t believe our government can pass any laws that are not supported by the people we elect to be our representatives, so the onus and responsibility are on us. Besides, the federal government is too big and slow to just land something like that on us without our having an opportunity to question it.
Big companies and corporations, on the other hand, are not subject to the same checks and balances as the government and put stuff over on us all the time by using attractive ads and cute commercials that tell us they are making our lives better, and we don’t think much about it because “the government is the problem.”
Are you aware that in 1970 CEOs made 20-30 times what the average worker did, and now they typically earn 300-400 times as much? Meanwhile, the federal minimum wage in 1970 was $1.60, which in today’s money would be about $12.10, but in fact today’s federal minimum wage is $7.25.
Are you aware that in 2023 Jeff Bezos, head of Amazon, made just under $8 million per hour? That his company is taxed at about 6% annually, whereas the average middle-class American probably pays over 20%?
Are you aware that only ten (10) corporations own most of the consumer goods we all buy?
Are you aware that only five (5) corporations control over 50% of the credit cards in the U.S.?
Starting with President Reagan (1981-1989), government regulation of corporate monopolies in this country has been increasingly ignored. And since so few companies now own and manage so much of our world, they can fix prices and interest rates pretty much how they want to.
At the same time, those corporations began to think their shareholders were more important than us consumers, and instead of keeping our prices down, they have focused increasingly on their profits. Our gas prices, for example, do not reflect that Big Oil is making the highest profits ever.
I could go on— for instance, are you aware of “shrinkflation”? Where the cereal or cracker package and the price are the same as always but the content is less, maybe 14.5 ounces instead of the original 16? Some brands of white vinegar are now only 4% acidity, and household pickling requires at least 5%. A lot of canning and pickling may spoil if we’re not paying attention.
My point is that, perhaps especially here in the West, tradition and hearsay encourage us to mistrust the federal government, but I think it’s what corporations are getting away with that really affects us and our families personally.
Please be curious and use the internet to look into things before accepting partisan scare tactics.
Mary Fahnestock-Thomas,
Hamilton
9
Letter to the editor: Have there been documented cases of noncitizens voting?
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
“The Heritage Foundation’s analysis of legal actions regarding election conduct found only 24 instances of noncitizens voting between (nationwide) 2003 and 2023. A study conducted by the Brennan Center for Justice analyzing 23.5 million votes across 42 jurisdictions in the 2016 general election concluded that there were approximately 30 instances of noncitizens casting votes. Any instance of illegally cast ballots by noncitizens has been investigated by the appropriate authorities, and there is no evidence that these votes—or any other instances of voter fraud—have been significant enough to impact any election’s outcome.” https://bipartisanpolicy.org/blog/four-things-to-know-about-noncitizen-voting/.
Thanks to the BBIA and the Ravalli County board of Realtors for sponsoring the local candidates forum. It was well attended and worth attending.
Election deniers Theresa Manzella and one audience member insisted on regurgitating nonexistent immigrant voters as defined above. The audience listened politely until more pertinent issues including taxes, mental health, school funding and infrastructure were discussed. As for me I yearned for the the day Wayne Rusk will defeat Theresa Manzella enabling public meeting’s discussions to return to meaningful local issues versus Christian right wack-a-doodle drivel.
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
10
Letter to the editor: Shannon O’Brien's skills far outweigh other candidates
Coming from a family in which no one could afford to attend college, my parents worked hard and instilled a strong desire to seek an education. I was the first to attend college in our family and treasured the opportunity.
Some Montanans have excellent public educational opportunities from preschool through college. The Montana Constitution even carries a mandate to develop the full educational potential of each citizen.
We see this in action with Bozeman, Kalispell Glacier, and Whitefish high schools ranking top three in the state. Unfortunately, these schools still rank well below national standards. Our report card from Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA 2022-23) showed more than half of Montana students lack proficiency in math, reading, and science.
As Montana voters, we have the privilege and responsibility to elect a candidate for superintendent of public instruction who will strive to improve competency in our children and work diligently to correct inadequate funding of public education. We need more teachers and higher salaries, but shortfalls this year required reduction in staffing and teacher hiring.
Shannon O’Brien is running for superintendent. Her broad background in education from K-12 to college and as dean of Missoula College, provides a solid basis of competency for this position. In addition, she was Gov. Steve Bullock’s education policy advisor, and is now a state senator fighting for public schools. Her exemplary skills provide a foundation for the superintendent position that far outweigh those of the Republican candidates in the coming primary.
Vote for the children. Vote for Shannon O’Brien.
Betty Kuffel,
Whitefish
11
Letter to the editor:
A recent letter to the editor addressed “The Parable”, which is the title of a previous letter to the editor, by deducing that the lesson of The Parable is that we are all, as tax payers, a kind of homeowner. All of us tax payers are responsible for unsheltered people sleeping on our sidewalks because first, they are here and they are as human as any of the rest of us. Second, many of them have been long time productive residents of Helena, fallen on hard times. We address other community needs such as roads, clean drinking water, waste water disposal, fire fighting, maintaining law and order, or even controlling the number of stray cats and dogs in the city with tax dollars. We pay a city animal control officer but we don’t have any Office of the Homeless! Mass homelessness is both life threatening and a drain on our local economy. It is a social problem in the first degree. An Office of the Homeless would be a more productive system than charging our mayor, and our city and county commissioners with the task of addressing this astronomical problem when they already have a full plate of pressing concerns.
Paul Pacini,
Helena
12
Letter to the editor: Bowen Greenwood is responsible choice
Bowen Greenwood is running for re-election as Clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. In the current charged political climate it's too easy to overlook this race; it doesn't have notoriety other races do. Yet it is important that whoever occupies this office be competent and experienced. No candidate opposing Bowen has these personal assets. Bowen is seeking his third term. As Clerk, Bowen is responsible for vetting and hiring responsible staff, assigning tasks to his team and assuring all relevant documents submitted to the Justices for review are complete and accurate in all respects. Failing here is not an option. And only Bowen Greenwood has the proven credentials to best insure our Justices and the court will be well served. Supporting Bowen Greenwood for re-election to Clerk of the Montana Supreme Court is the responsible choice in the up coming primary and general elections.
Rich Bloom,
Helena
13
Letter to the editor: Greenwood is responsive, fast, thorough
I’m writing to support Bowen Greenwood’s reelection as clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. My support is based upon observations formed as a state legislator and as a practicing attorney.
As an attorney who has had recent cases pending in the Montana Supreme Court, I can state with confidence that Bowen has brought good skills to the office, resulting in competent and responsive service.
Supreme Court practitioners know that Bowen is responsive: he’s fast and thorough with the answer to every question. When the Supreme Court schedules oral argument in cases, Bowen goes above and beyond to help attorneys on the logistical questions in advance of hearings.
For the benefit of both the public and practitioners, Bowen started several major initiatives to help make the justice system more transparent to the people. He emails a report of the court’s opinions to anyone in Montana who wants to keep updated. He keeps a list of cases in the news on the website, so people can easily look up cases they may have read about.
As a legislator focused on state budget issues, I have been pleased that Mr. Greenwood has held the line on the expenditures required to run his office.
Bowen Greenwood has done an excellent job as clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. Montanans should want to keep him in the role.
Bill Mercer,
Billings
14
Letter to the editor: Dan Wilson for Associate Justice
Like most of my friends, I’m tired of the negativity constantly swirling around us every day — especially in the political arena. That’s why it is so refreshing to see and read about a candidate who takes the high road and runs his campaign focusing on policies rather than personalities.
Such a man is Dan Wilson. Dan has successfully served our communities as a district judge for several years and now is a candidate for Associate Justice of the Montana Supreme Court.
I’ve known Dan for many years and have found him to be an honest man, one who is a good listener, has a wealth of legal knowledge, and a man with integrity. As an Associate Judge, I believe these qualities, plus his thoroughness, attention to detail, and relentless work ethic will not only make him an asset to our state court, but will enable him to adjudicate the many challenging cases with fairness, and an adherence to the rule of law of our state and our Constitution.
Let’s help keep our Montana Supreme Court where people are heard and a place where progress and common sense can work together to showcase the Montana values we all share.
Please vote for Dan Wilson for Associate Justice of the Montana Supreme Court.
Nancy Ross,
Kalispell
15
Letter to the editor: BLM prioritizing health of our wild spaces
Like most Montanans, I take the health and management of our public lands very seriously. That’s why when the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) finally released its Public Lands Rule last week, I knew I could breathe a bit easier about our public lands management. I saw Tracy Stone-Manning, the Director of the BLM, speak in Missoula a few weeks ago and was encouraged by her message about her love of Montana's public lands and the need for updated management practices.
The Public Lands Rule would require the BLM to consider conservation, outdoor recreation, intact landscapes, wildlife habitat and restoration as equally important as traditional extractive activities in its multiple-use management. This is critical as our management of public lands requires flexibility to take into account the effects of climate change and to prioritize landscape health when deciding the range of public land usage.
With the threats to our public lands piling up seemingly every day, it is heartening to know that the BLM, the largest public lands manager in the nation, is prioritizing the health of our wild spaces and considering all options available to them to keep our public lands thriving.
Allison Wilson,
Missoula
16
Letter to the editor: Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
I am writing this letter in support of the reelection of Rep. David Bedey for House District 86. David is one of the best legislators I have met. I first met Rep. Bedey a few sessions ago as we were on opposite sides of a veteran bill he was sponsoring. Although he met resistance to his bill, he was not deterred. Many legislators would charge forward and push their bill without any regard to opposing views. Not Rep. Bedey. He engaged anyone and everyone he could to hear their concerns and work to address them. His unbiased efforts led to the passage of significant veteran legislation in support of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran who has worked with legislators for over four decades to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that Rep. David Bedey was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
David’s expertise and genuine concern for his constituents is not limited to veteran issues. I watched him work tirelessly, researching the issues, asking questions of those around him and making decisions based upon the best information he could find. That is the kind of legislator that must be returned to Helena to support the constituents of House District 86.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
17
Letter to the editor: Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
I am writing this letter in support of the reelection of Rep. David Bedey for House District 86. David is one of the best legislators I have met. I first met Rep. Bedey a few sessions ago as we were on opposite sides of a veteran bill he was sponsoring. Although he met resistance to his bill, he was not deterred. Many legislators would charge forward and push their bill without any regard to opposing views. Not Rep. Bedey. He engaged anyone and everyone he could to hear their concerns and work to address them. His unbiased efforts led to the passage of significant veteran legislation in support of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran who has worked with legislators for over four decades to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that Rep. David Bedey was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
David’s expertise and genuine concern for his constituents is not limited to veteran issues. I watched him work tirelessly, researching the issues, asking questions of those around him and making decisions based upon the best information he could find. That is the kind of legislator that must be returned to Helena to support the constituents of House District 86.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
BLM prioritizing health of our wild spaces
Like most Montanans, I take the health and management of our public lands very seriously. That’s why when the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) finally released its Public Lands Rule last week, I knew I could breathe a bit easier about our public lands management. I saw Tracy Stone-Manning, the Director of the BLM, speak in Missoula a few weeks ago and was encouraged by her message about her love of Montana’s public lands and the need for updated management practices.
The Public Lands Rule would require the BLM to consider conservation, outdoor recreation, intact landscapes, wildlife habitat and restoration as equally important as traditional extractive activities in its multiple-use management. This is critical as our management of public lands requires flexibility to take into account the effects of climate change and to prioritize landscape health when deciding the range of public land usage.
With the threats to our public lands piling up seemingly every day, it is heartening to know that the BLM, the largest public lands manager in the nation, is prioritizing the health of our wild spaces and considering all options available to them to keep our public lands thriving.
Allison Wilson,
Missoula
18
Letter to the editor: Weeds
You can PULL ‘em,
And then CULL ‘em.
You can SPRAY ‘em,
Which will SLAY ‘em.
You can MOW ‘em,
Or you can HOE ‘em!
Just PLEASE, PLEASE,
Do what will SLOW ‘em!
Jane Lambert,
Stevensville, former Ravalli County Weed Board member
19
Letter to the editor: Choice for SD44 is easy - Wayne Rusk
Wayne Rusk is a candidate I wish each of you knew personally. I am proud to call him a friend after knowing him several years.
Wayne is representing us now in the Montana Legislature, in House District 88. He proved himself to be a solid conservative this past session and took tough votes that he knew people could question but took them because it was the right thing to do. Looking at a yes or no vote does not tell the whole story. He is happy to answer any questions on the votes he took.
Wayne is running for Senate District 44 and so will still be representing us here in Florence and Stevensville plus the House district south of Stevensville. I just read a letter by a Matthew Sullivan in the 4/17 Star. In it he states that Rusk is running to ‘get back at’ Manzella. First of all, with all of the things a candidate for office goes through, I have NEVER heard Mr. Rusk give any indication he is undertaking this huge task to ‘get back’ at anyone! Wayne is a very principled man who has worked diligently to serve the people of Florence, Stevensville and the State of Montana and Wayne has found common ground where others weren’t even looking and he has done so without compromising his core principles.
Wayne, and his family, are sacrificing a lot to enter this race because he believes the people deserve a choice. We can vote for the incumbent who represents the John Birch Society and who sadly chooses to use every negative trick and untruth in the book to win an election or we can vote for Wayne Rusk — a true conservative, whose optimism and hard work have earned him great respect with his fellow legislators.
As a former legislator here in the valley, I am very proud to endorse Wayne Rusk for SD44.
RUSK or Manzella……pretty darned easy choice!
Sharon Greef,
Former HD88 Representative
20
Letter to the editor: Sheehy not fit for U.S. Senate
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
Tim Sheehy’s Senate campaign received a shot in the arm recently or was it years ago? As a highly trained Navy Seal in Afghanistan he took a hit for his buddies by withholding information about a bullet in his arm. Three years after discharge, he further protected his buddies by shooting himself in the arm while falling in an injury that resulted in a $525 fine for illegally discharging a firearm in a National Park. The guy is obviously a victim of medical theft as he is now short one bullet in his arm? The park ranger looked, it was not in his gun!
Sounds like real old-time Montana values at work. While traveling in possession of properly locked and loaded firearm, in a dangerous wilderness Montana park with wild tourists all around, he shoots his arm while in the parking lot. His cover story firmly places his foot in his mouth. Let’s hope he is not presently armed and further takes aim at his foot.
What a statement of military character. He’ll fight for abortion bans and preserve Montana billionaires tax breaks. Let’s run him for the U.S. Senate!
I think I’d rather vote for a Big Sandy farmer (pun intended).
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
21
Letter to the editor: Wayne Rusk wants to do what's best for Montana
I am writing this letter in support of Wayne Rusk and his candidacy for Senate District 44. I had the honor of working with Wayne during the 2023, 68th Legislative Session and was pleased to find him as a thoughtful and honest legislator. It was my observation that he was very respectful of his constituency and wanted to do what was best for Montana.
I have advocated for military and Montana veteran issues at the state legislature for over 40 years. While Wayne never served, he had a solid commitment to understand our issues, ask probing questions, and make his decisions based on the facts. I was pleased to discover that Wayne Rusk, without fail, was a solid supporter of our Montana Veterans and our National Guard.
I am a 38-year veteran of the U.S. Air Force/Montana National Guard and a former State Representative who has worked with legislators to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 Session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee and assessed the vote of multiple legislators. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that your Representative, Wayne Rusk, was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
It is because of his solid record with our veterans and National Guard members, I ask you to support the election of Wayne Rusk Senate District 44.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
22
Letter to the editor: Property Tax Assistance Program
With discussions with the governor, the filing application deadline for the property tax assistance program has been extended until June 1. This program can help citizens on a fixed or limited income by reducing the tax rate on their home.
To be eligible, there are three important facts:
- You must own or currently be under contract to purchase a home or mobile/manufactured home.
- You must live in the home as a primary residence for a least seven months of the year.
- You must have a 2022 Federal Adjusted Gross Income, excluding capital and income losses less than: *single $27,621 or *married or head of household $37,019.
The assistance level can be from a 30% to 80% reduction of the normal tax rate. To find information on your status, contact your local State Department of Revenue office or call the state office in Helena at 406-444-6900.
Rep. Denley M. Loge,
St. Regis
23
Letter to the editor: Sharyl Allen is committed to our children's education
Today, I stand with great pride to endorse Sharyl Allen for Superintendent of Public Instruction, a leader whose commitment to our children's education reflects Montana's spirit of resilience and community.
Sharyl has consistently demonstrated an innovative approach to education, addressing urgent challenges with swift and thoughtful actions that drive our educational system forward. Her career, marked by a commitment to modern educational practices, showcases her readiness to face issues head-on, even under personal challenges.
Her spiritual depth and focus on family values align closely with Montana’s ethos of unity and independence. Sharyl's compassion and empathy embody the spiritual and cultural traditions of our state, advocating for every Montanan.
A lifelong educator, Sharyl’s tireless advocacy extends beyond the classroom. She works relentlessly to ensure that every student, teacher, and district has the support needed to unlock potential and achieve success.
In challenging times, Sharyl has proven her ability to uphold our values and confront significant issues directly. Education — the cornerstone of our children's future — is facing critical threats from various external pressures, including societal challenges that undermine our foundational values. Sharyl stands ready to lead our educational system through these trials with unwavering dedication.
I urge you to support Sharyl Allen for Superintendent of Public Instruction. A vote for Sharyl is a vote for a leader who embodies the very best of Montana — innovation, integrity, and a deep commitment to the future of our children.
Let's unite behind her to secure a bright, enduring future for all Montanan children.
Robert Hoffman,
Helena
24
Letter to the editor: Binkley is a staunch supporter of our veterans
- Roger Hagan, Great Falls
I am writing this letter in support of Representative Michele Binkley and her candidacy for House District 85. As a 40 plus year advocate at the State Legislature for Montana veteran and military interests, I can affirm without concern, that Rep. Binkley is a staunch supporter of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran of the U.S. Air Force/Montana National Guard and a former state representative who has worked with legislators to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. In the past four years I have had the opportunity to work with Michele and I have found her to be truly engaged in seeking knowledge of our military and veteran issues. She is deliberate in her consideration of our efforts, asks questions about our concerns, and seeks to reach a reasoned solution.
The 2023 68th Legislative Session was a particularly brisk session for our veterans and military members. I tracked dozens of bills in committee and assessed the vote of multiple legislators. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that your representative, Michele Binkley, was 100% in voting for our Montana veterans and military members.
It is because of her stellar record with our veterans, I ask you to support the re-election of Rep. Michele Binkley for House District 85.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
25
Letter to the editor: Vote for Monica Tranel
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
The Ricketts Road one million dollar repair check is a late federal Easter ham (political pork). Much needed and delayed repairs of local roads should be completed using our federal tax dollars. Let’s be honest. Ryan Zinke using his power as the lowest rated member on the House Appropriations Committee; agreed to sign a bill keeping the government open conditioned on inclusion of community projects funding. (appropriations.senate.gov/fy-2024-congressionally-directed-spending)
Zinke’s press release made no mention of his 2021 failure to vote for the American Rescue Plan and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. By comparison not signing either bill defines a three years later 2024 road repair for what it is “an election year eating of the pork with local politicians!” Where is Zinke’s cry “budget deficits are a national security threat?”
I suggest voters sack him and the horse he rode in on as past disgraced Secretary of Interior. A simple way to place the credit correctly and acknowledge his earlier equine droppings is for voters to vote for Monica Tranel in November’s election.
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
26
Letter to the editor: Conspiracy?
- Mary Fahnestock-Thomas, Hamilton
Everyone’s doing it, so hey!
My theory is that Donald Trump is important to his “handlers,” including some but not all prominent Republicans, to get the votes and win the presidency, and then Project 2025 will take over while he follows his own personal agenda pretty much on the sidelines.
Not familiar with Project 2025 (officially the Presidential Transition Project)? What I have read looks more like trying to sound good than concrete steps to a workable government, but it certainly is right-wing. Wikipedia offers a summary and background (and no, Wikipedia is not just for high-schoolers trying to write essays on time, says this PhD).
The thing is this: Trump is under increasing financial, personal and political pressure. Having put up a bond to cover the $93 million for sexually assaulting E. Jean Carroll, he was clearly struggling to come up with the $450 million he owes the state of New York for financial fraud, so he appealed and the court agreed to settle for $175 million for starters.
He did come up with that, but investigation is finding it to be pretty shaky. And his trial for mis-using campaign funds as hush-money about sexual affairs prior to the 2016 election is now underway in Manhattan, and he looks tired and angry and frazzled and is apparently tending to fall asleep in the courtroom.
Hitler was helped to power by people who figured that they would be able to work around him to realize their own political ambitions. It didn’t so much turn out that way for many of them, but in this case, because Trump’s focus is himself, not an ideology, it might work, and I think the writers and collaborators of Project 2025 are counting on that.
I do not trust people or organizations that appear to be single-mindedly ideological and ambitious, such as Stephen Miller, Steve Bannon, The Heritage Foundation, and so many others listed on Project 2025.
My own ideology? Kindness, and treating others the way I want to be treated.
Mary Fahnestock-Thomas,
Hamilton
27
Letter to the editor: Put the pressure on
- Star Jameson, Hamilton
As our rivers and creeks flow way below their banks this year, I am concerned about water shortages for crops and cattle in the heat of the summer. I hear others discussing this as well. By professional management I assume we will come through with what we need and my agricultural neighbors will not suffer setbacks. In the meantime, I need to say that a mine similar to the proposed Sheep Creek Mine used 278 million gallons of water per year for its operations. I’m not a geologist, but when I consider that kind of drain on our watershed I know it’s a threat to the whole valley’s ground water supply.
Montana has always tried to develop its resources, sometimes to the extreme. Now we’re looking at a “rare earth” economy to possibly replace our coal economy. I’m okay with that…adjustment to economic realities is the name of this era we’re in. But I do not want 500-700 foot deep holes in the summits of our beautiful Bitterroot Mountains because of a mining model which has been proven to leak hundreds of gallons of toxic water into our fisheries. There are other options, some already established. The Berkeley Pit, for example, is being tapped for the rare minerals in its waters.
We Montanans have already let down our guard with our antiquated mining laws which hundreds (really!) of now-defunct corporations have taken advantage of. (There are 8000 abandoned mines in the state currently.) In at least five instances it is you and I who are paying for site cleanup because the corporations have conveniently gone bankrupt. Do ask the candidates you want to vote for what they will do about new mining legislation, and what do they think about Sheep Creek.
I came here 50 years ago for many of the same reasons folks are coming now. Clean water (threatened), open spaces (threatened), clean air (pray that July is fire free), and neighbors that practice these same values. We need to put the pressure on the Forest Service, Fish, Wildlife and Parks, Bureau of Land Management and our local politicians. If we don’t, we stand to lose far more than we can imagine.
Star Jameson,
Hamilton
28
Letter to the editor: Vote against nullification
- Mike Cressler, Hamilton
In my research on the candidates for the Montana Legislature in Ravalli County, I’ve discovered to my dismay that one of the leaders of the nullification movement, Sen. Theresa Manzella, holds office in Ravalli County.
The nullification movement misinterprets the U.S. Constitution to give any state the right to nullify or invalidate, and thus ignore, any federal law that it considers unconstitutional or otherwise in violation of the Constitution. Nullification is not the law and never has been.
Nevertheless, in the last legislative session, Sen. Manzella sponsored Senate Bill 434, which was intended to give political structure and legitimacy to the nullification movement. When adopted by at least nine states, this bill would have created a political body called a “Constitution Settlement Commission of the States,” whose purpose would have been to define what powers the states have “granted” to the federal government in the U.S. Constitution.
If enacted, the bill would allow the participating states through this commission to issue decisions, like a court, on whether a particular federal law is constitutional or not and, if not, recommend that the federal law be ignored. This is nullification — pure and simple.
Fortunately, the Montana Senate recognized this nullification bill for what it was and voted it down with only about a half dozen voting for it. But we cannot give Sen. Manzella another chance to introduce this radically un-American bill again or anything like it. Vote for Wayne Rusk!
Mike Cressler,
Hamilton
29
Letter to the editor: Our courts have final say
Don Kaltschmidt’s April 13 attack on Montana’s courts and judges, while predictable for a state Republican Party chairman, reflects woeful ignorance of, and perhaps even contempt for, the U.S. and Montana constitutions.
Our courts, not legislatures, governors, attorneys general, and certainly not partisan political party chairs, thankfully have the final say in interpreting and applying these laws to protect individual rights and freedoms.
Montana’s Constitution ranks among our country’s best in enshrining, defining, and shielding these rights from partisan political meddling or worse. I may personally disagree with some constitutional court case decisions, but I never question their legitimacy or the power of our judges to make them because I do not want my rights messed with by political hacks.
Legislatures have their legitimate place in our government system, as I know well from my law faculty Advanced Legislation course experiences seeing UM students draft some 130 bills enacted as current Montana statutes. I respect what legislatures do, but recognize their lawmaking powers cease when used to violate our individual constitutional rights.
Regrettably, Montana sees this far too often because a majority of our legislators seem clueless about what they can and cannot legally do. The solution to Kaltschmidt’s concern requires him to show actual, not fake, leadership by urging his fellow Republicans in the Montana Legislature to stop passing so many unconstitutional laws and then blaming judges who do their jobs in striking them down.
If he can’t or won’t do this, he should stick to selling cars.
David Aronofsky,
Missoula
30
Letter to the editor: We must make sure democracy survives
Just over six months left.
That is the short time left before what promises to be one of the most, if not the most, consequential elections ever faced by our democracy. Are you ready? Did you realize that candidate filing deadlines have already come and gone in Montana? Thus, our choices among candidates running for election have already narrowed. Next, the primaries will take place in less than two months, reducing our choices even more.
At that point, in many cases we are already faced with making a choice among the proverbial “lesser of evils.”
The question is: “Will Democracy survive?” Who has the answer? We do. As voters, we must help make sure our democracy survives.
Don’t think there’s any real threat? Look around. Investigate the actions and votes of those politicians who represent you. Don’t forget to explore every aspect of your national, state, and local candidates’ records and promises. Are they likely to work for you and all of Montana or primarily focused on maintaining their own powers? If one or more has been most interested in the latter, fire them.
Even if that means choosing the “lesser of evils,” say "you’re fired” and start right away finding new political leaders who will work for you and not just themselves. Recognize that, more than ever, our democracy’s survival depends on the success of our effort.
Galen McKibben,
Helena
31
Letter to the editor: Tim Sheehy's bad week
It's been a bad week for novice Republican Senate candidate Tim Sheehy. You'll recall that the two pillars of his campaign are his military service and his success as a businessman. Both took a hit this week. First, it came out that Mr. Sheehy either lied to the Park Service about a purported gunshot incident at Logan Pass that may, or may not, have led to a wound; or lied to his superiors in the military about a wound he received, but didn't report, in Afghanistan. Or maybe he did shoot himself in Glacier and is lying about it on the campaign to make it appear its a combat wound. In any case, it shows he's pretty loose with the truth, to put it mildly. Then the second shoe drops— it is reported that his Bozeman based company lost $77 million dollars last year. And that it may end up shutting down due to these losses, and/or his campaign for Senate. So much for the "successful business man" schtick. And oh yes, what about those employees who may then lose their jobs and security? Of course, we know that in this MAGA era, the truth doesn't matter, and a business fraud can become president. Montanans would be wise to choose the tried and true, John Tester, for Senate, he's as straight a shooter.
Kim Wilson,
Helena
More like this...
'; oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append(sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } }); } // Build engagement set $.each(oResponse.assets, function(index) { if (index == 1 && sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == null) { sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = oResponse.assets[0].id; } // Display assets once origin is found // Find origin then begin displaying assets if (bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { if (this.id == sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Found orgin a second time. Stop gathering assets and kill next_url bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = null; oEngagementMore_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.remove(); } else if (bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false && this.id != '69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37') { // Display asset var sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = ''; if (this.content.includes('engagement-asset') && iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 < iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 ++; sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 += '
' + this.content + '
'; } } } else { if (this.id == sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Origin found. Begin displaying assets bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; } else { // Origin found is false. Skip asset // Fail-safe in case origin is not present in set. This can be removed when origin is fixed. if (bFirstRun_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { // Stored first id sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = this.id; bFirstRun_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = false; } else if (this.id == sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // We've started again. Force origin sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37; bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; } // end Fail-safe } } // Append engagement assets to container oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append(sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); // Stop traversing asset array if (iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 >= iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; return false; } }); // Include block_id on newly added list items oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.find('.engagement-item.original').each(function() { var sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = scrubURL($(this).find("a.centered-content-link").attr("href")); if(sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37!="javascript:void(0)"){ // Add content discovery tracking sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 += '#tncms-source=endcard-gallery'; // Add to image and headlines links $(this).removeClass('original').find("a.centered-content-link").attr("href", sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } }); // Check next URL if (sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 && bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false) { // if origin hasn't been found yet and we hit next_url. Trigger the set to pull in again. if (bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false) { // No origin yet. Call the populate function __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } else { // Append sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 to engagement set oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append('
'); if (iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 < iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Get next url and request more assets __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(oEngagementMore_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.data('next-url')); } } } // Add total count to container if (bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { // Add total count to container oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.attr("data-engagement-total", iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); // Remove engagement loading spinner oEngagementSpinner_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.remove(); return false; } } else { // Empty asset set returned. Go back in for a real set if(__tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].attempts<2){ if(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37==null||sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37==""){ sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = "/news/local/hamilton-speaks-up-recently-published-letters-to-the-editor/collection_69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37.html"; } __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].attempts++; } } }); } } // Rewrite URL for preview // TODO move to one location function scrubURL(sURL) { if (typeof sURL != 'undefined'){ return sURL; } }
Letter to the editor: National Stuttering Awareness Week
May 12-18 is National Stuttering Awareness Week. One in every 100 people stutter. That’s 80 million people worldwide! Yet stuttering is often misunderstood and even laughed at.
To address the many myths surrounding this complex disorder, the Stuttering Foundation has compiled a list of “75 Must-Use Resources for the Stuttering Community” — available free on our website: StutteringHelp.org.
The Foundation’s most popular content represents a mix of time-tested favorites and newer innovations:
- Drawings and Letters from Kids webpagefeaturing submissions from children around the world and published in our magazine.
- Answers for Employers brochureanswering frequent questions from employers received by the Foundation each year.
- Self-Therapy for the Stutterer e-bookwritten by Founder Malcolm Fraser in 1978.
- List of Famous People Who Stutter webpagecontinuously updated with many celebrities, sports heroes, writers and world leaders.
- Podcast webpagenow in its sixth season with more than 100,000 listeners.
- Advice to Those Who Stutter audio bookdrafted in 1972 and updated by 28 therapists who stutter themselves.
- I Stutter ID Card webpagehelping people identify themselves in a nonverbal way.
Jane Fraser, president,
The Stuttering Foundation
Letter to the editor: Vote in the primary to be represented
Everyone in Ravalli County knows that practically all our elected officials are not only Republican, but increasingly extreme right-wing Republicans. We also know that since it’s very difficult for a Democrat to win the general election, whoever wins the Republican primary will be our representative or senator. The strategy that the extreme segment of the Ravalli County Republican Party uses to help their candidate win is to make sure there are multiple candidates in the primary to split the vote among more moderate candidates.
This is the case in the Senate District 44 race. There is a Democrat on the ballot, but no Democrat in the valley recognizes him or knows what he stands for. Similarly, Brad Davis, a Republican, says he wants to be a legislator to make sure his trapping hobby is protected by amending the Constitution (a right that is already assured in our State Constitution, by the way). But he is just attempting to take votes from Wayne Rusk. Having a third Republican and a phony Democrat in the primary is a desperate move on Manzella’s part to split the vote because, in my opinion, she can’t win on her merits (if she has any).
Republicans continually remind everyone that we don’t have a Democracy, but that we have a Representative Republic. If you want to be fairly represented, study and evaluate the candidates and vote accordingly. How well you are represented in Helena depends on it.
Margaret Gorski,
Stevensville
Letter to the editor: Rusk will make Bitterrooters proud
In recent days, Wayne Rusk, a committed conservative candidate for State Senator SD44 seat, has faced a negative mailer campaign funded by a supporter of his opponent, Theresa Manzella. The man behind the mailer, Bob Kubiak, has targeted not only Rusk and the citizens of Victor, but also Rusk's children and their friends, by mailing the flyer that he cut and pasted about Rusk's past life to them embarrassing the children over events that happened more than 10 years ago. Kubiak displayed a despicable lack of decency by targeting children who can do nothing about man's vile behavior. It seems that Kubiak is a member of the John Birch contingency who are overstepping boundaries of decent behavior in this valley. Join me in voting for RUSK for SD44, who will protect children and not allow them to be targeted for political purposes. Rusk will protect the kids and the citizens of the valley, and write superb legislation to help keep them safe and secure in their home and communities, and most important, he will make Bitterrooters proud they elected him. Rusk has committed his life to the Heavenly Father that has blessed him and he will not fail in passing the blessings to the community by being the best legislator they could ever hope for.
Helen Sabin,
Corvallis
Letter to the editor: Continuing support for Wayne Rusk
Two years ago, I felt the need to write a letter in support of Wayne Rusk in his bid for the House District 88 seat. I was completely convinced of Wayne’s ability to serve our community in the state legislature, and having watched closely during this last session, I was not disappointed. Wayne proved himself to be that level-headed man I touted him to be. He measured his words; he thought before he spoke; and his actions proved him to be the deep man of conviction I know him to be. Wayne’s patriotism, his care and concern for his community and his state, and his understanding of our history and foundations came fully to the forefront. He is approachable and open to hear other opinions, and then make the hard decisions on his own based on careful research.
It disappoints me that Wayne and his family find him under attack again, with the same tired, outdated allegations we heard two years ago. While I am confident that citizens in Ravalli County, specifically in Senate District 44, will not be duped by this type of politics, I once again wish to voice my wholehearted support of Wayne in the upcoming primary election.
Please vote for Wayne Rusk in Senate District 44.
Chris Hoffman, Ravalli County Sheriff (ret.),
Former Ravalli County Commissioner
Letter to the editor: Voice your concerns about our overheating climate
Montana is feeling the effects of climate change first-hand: heatwaves, droughts, dwindling snowpacks, wildfires and floods. The severity of wildfire smoke prompts people to leave the state for the summer.
In June, Montana Citizens’ Climate Lobby volunteers are headed to D.C. to meet Senators Daines and Tester and Representatives Zinke and Rosendale. Their mission? To advocate for proactive climate bills to avoid the worst of climate change, and protect us from harm.
Key legislation includes the Energy Innovation Act, Increased Technical Service Providers Access Act, the BIG WIRES Act, and the Prove It Act.
Combined, these bills reduce government spending, protect our health, and cut our carbon pollution 50% by 2030 in the most cost-effective way. They help accelerate transmission line permitting and construction, and pave the way for clean, reliable domestic energy. They encourage other countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions like the carbon dioxide that is produced by burning fossil fuels.
You can help.
Contact our members of Congress and voice your concerns about our overheating climate. Ask them to enact market-based climate policies. They only respond to us if they hear from us.
Endorse these policies! See https://citizensclimatelobby.org/our-climate-solutions/endorse/.
Serious about fighting climate change and want to volunteer? Join us! CCL is a nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy climate change organization focused on national climate policies.
We all breathe the same air and need a safe place to live, reliable water sources, food security, and a stable climate. Together, we can all win and protect our communities now and for the future.
Alexandra Amonette,
Big Timber
Letter to the editor: Ethics matter; vote for Wayne Rusk
The character qualifications couldn’t be more opposite than the choice between Wayne Rusk and Manzella. Wayne Rusk earned a record of integrity while serving in the state House of Representatives last session, while Manzella’s record was less than stellar and at the least, self serving. These two candidates couldn’t be more opposite. Last campaign season Manzella used Wayne’s donor list and contacted the donors using her official Senate stationery without the permission of Rusk. She advised Rusk’s donors that they shouldn’t vote for Rusk but vote for her. On state stationery! A law was passed in the 2023 legislature to prevent this occurring again.
The positive side of ethical behavior is now being shown in the recent ads of endorsem*nt in support of Wayne by the legislators from Ravalli County who have served in the past 30 years plus current and past Ravalli County officials. This is powerful recognition plus endorsem*nt by the folks that know from their own experience what it takes to accomplish good public service and the excellent operation of Ravalli County and the state government. Ethics matter… endorsem*nts matter…character counts!
You won’t be disappointed if you elect Wayne Rusk for Senate District 44.
Ed Greef and Ray Hawk
Past Representatives HD88, HD90
Florence
Letter to the editor: Disappointed in Republican leaders
I am unhappy with Montana’s elected Republicans and how their majority recklessly drives the state into one ditch and then another. Weekly reports highlighting improprieties stemming from the governor’s office, to the attorney general, to the Office of Public Instruction, to the Public Service Commission, are intolerable.
As leaders, they gave us higher property taxes and fewer dollars for schools. They managed to oversee cuts in Medicaid funding and watched seniors being thrown out of closing facilities. Knudsen’s office shamelessly attacks the courts for protecting Montanans from suffering under unconstitutional laws approved by Don Kaltschmidt. Superintendent Elsie Arntzen leads her own war against public schools. And, not surprising, culture wars are her bag, public education never was.
When I remember watching the majority use its time drafting unconstitutional bills in an attempt to legislatively re-engineer our social, environmental and economic landscapes to match its hom*ophobic, poacher-friendly, tax dodging, collective ethos; I fear I’ll wake up one day surrounded by hillbillies and being forced to attend nationally televised Trump Bible Study sessions before being sent to work in a Bozeman sweatshop cranking out guns and traps.
I want a responsible government. I want elected representatives who perform their service with respect for those they serve. I do not want to live under an oppressive and paranoid, dogmatic regime that takes its marching orders from an unscrupulous, grifter.
The GOP is dead. In its place rises the spawn of a side-show barker, pretentious, dull, and selfish. One by one, I shall vote them out.
Jeff Meide,
Billings
Letter to the editor: Microplastics in everything
- Mary Fahnestock-Thomas, Hamilton
Today I heard a new friend telling another new friend that there is a law “coming down the pike” that will take all control of our children’s health away from us.
I don’t believe our government can pass any laws that are not supported by the people we elect to be our representatives, so the onus and responsibility are on us. Besides, the federal government is too big and slow to just land something like that on us without our having an opportunity to question it.
Big companies and corporations, on the other hand, are not subject to the same checks and balances as the government and put stuff over on us all the time by using attractive ads and cute commercials that tell us they are making our lives better, and we don’t think much about it because “the government is the problem.”
Are you aware that in 1970 CEOs made 20-30 times what the average worker did, and now they typically earn 300-400 times as much? Meanwhile, the federal minimum wage in 1970 was $1.60, which in today’s money would be about $12.10, but in fact today’s federal minimum wage is $7.25.
Are you aware that in 2023 Jeff Bezos, head of Amazon, made just under $8 million per hour? That his company is taxed at about 6% annually, whereas the average middle-class American probably pays over 20%?
Are you aware that only ten (10) corporations own most of the consumer goods we all buy?
Are you aware that only five (5) corporations control over 50% of the credit cards in the U.S.?
Starting with President Reagan (1981-1989), government regulation of corporate monopolies in this country has been increasingly ignored. And since so few companies now own and manage so much of our world, they can fix prices and interest rates pretty much how they want to.
At the same time, those corporations began to think their shareholders were more important than us consumers, and instead of keeping our prices down, they have focused increasingly on their profits. Our gas prices, for example, do not reflect that Big Oil is making the highest profits ever.
I could go on— for instance, are you aware of “shrinkflation”? Where the cereal or cracker package and the price are the same as always but the content is less, maybe 14.5 ounces instead of the original 16? Some brands of white vinegar are now only 4% acidity, and household pickling requires at least 5%. A lot of canning and pickling may spoil if we’re not paying attention.
My point is that, perhaps especially here in the West, tradition and hearsay encourage us to mistrust the federal government, but I think it’s what corporations are getting away with that really affects us and our families personally.
Please be curious and use the internet to look into things before accepting partisan scare tactics.
Mary Fahnestock-Thomas,
Hamilton
Letter to the editor: Have there been documented cases of noncitizens voting?
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
“The Heritage Foundation’s analysis of legal actions regarding election conduct found only 24 instances of noncitizens voting between (nationwide) 2003 and 2023. A study conducted by the Brennan Center for Justice analyzing 23.5 million votes across 42 jurisdictions in the 2016 general election concluded that there were approximately 30 instances of noncitizens casting votes. Any instance of illegally cast ballots by noncitizens has been investigated by the appropriate authorities, and there is no evidence that these votes—or any other instances of voter fraud—have been significant enough to impact any election’s outcome.” https://bipartisanpolicy.org/blog/four-things-to-know-about-noncitizen-voting/.
Thanks to the BBIA and the Ravalli County board of Realtors for sponsoring the local candidates forum. It was well attended and worth attending.
Election deniers Theresa Manzella and one audience member insisted on regurgitating nonexistent immigrant voters as defined above. The audience listened politely until more pertinent issues including taxes, mental health, school funding and infrastructure were discussed. As for me I yearned for the the day Wayne Rusk will defeat Theresa Manzella enabling public meeting’s discussions to return to meaningful local issues versus Christian right wack-a-doodle drivel.
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
Letter to the editor: Shannon O’Brien's skills far outweigh other candidates
Coming from a family in which no one could afford to attend college, my parents worked hard and instilled a strong desire to seek an education. I was the first to attend college in our family and treasured the opportunity.
Some Montanans have excellent public educational opportunities from preschool through college. The Montana Constitution even carries a mandate to develop the full educational potential of each citizen.
We see this in action with Bozeman, Kalispell Glacier, and Whitefish high schools ranking top three in the state. Unfortunately, these schools still rank well below national standards. Our report card from Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA 2022-23) showed more than half of Montana students lack proficiency in math, reading, and science.
As Montana voters, we have the privilege and responsibility to elect a candidate for superintendent of public instruction who will strive to improve competency in our children and work diligently to correct inadequate funding of public education. We need more teachers and higher salaries, but shortfalls this year required reduction in staffing and teacher hiring.
Shannon O’Brien is running for superintendent. Her broad background in education from K-12 to college and as dean of Missoula College, provides a solid basis of competency for this position. In addition, she was Gov. Steve Bullock’s education policy advisor, and is now a state senator fighting for public schools. Her exemplary skills provide a foundation for the superintendent position that far outweigh those of the Republican candidates in the coming primary.
Vote for the children. Vote for Shannon O’Brien.
Betty Kuffel,
Whitefish
Letter to the editor:
A recent letter to the editor addressed “The Parable”, which is the title of a previous letter to the editor, by deducing that the lesson of The Parable is that we are all, as tax payers, a kind of homeowner. All of us tax payers are responsible for unsheltered people sleeping on our sidewalks because first, they are here and they are as human as any of the rest of us. Second, many of them have been long time productive residents of Helena, fallen on hard times. We address other community needs such as roads, clean drinking water, waste water disposal, fire fighting, maintaining law and order, or even controlling the number of stray cats and dogs in the city with tax dollars. We pay a city animal control officer but we don’t have any Office of the Homeless! Mass homelessness is both life threatening and a drain on our local economy. It is a social problem in the first degree. An Office of the Homeless would be a more productive system than charging our mayor, and our city and county commissioners with the task of addressing this astronomical problem when they already have a full plate of pressing concerns.
Paul Pacini,
Helena
Letter to the editor: Bowen Greenwood is responsible choice
Bowen Greenwood is running for re-election as Clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. In the current charged political climate it's too easy to overlook this race; it doesn't have notoriety other races do. Yet it is important that whoever occupies this office be competent and experienced. No candidate opposing Bowen has these personal assets. Bowen is seeking his third term. As Clerk, Bowen is responsible for vetting and hiring responsible staff, assigning tasks to his team and assuring all relevant documents submitted to the Justices for review are complete and accurate in all respects. Failing here is not an option. And only Bowen Greenwood has the proven credentials to best insure our Justices and the court will be well served. Supporting Bowen Greenwood for re-election to Clerk of the Montana Supreme Court is the responsible choice in the up coming primary and general elections.
Rich Bloom,
Helena
Letter to the editor: Greenwood is responsive, fast, thorough
I’m writing to support Bowen Greenwood’s reelection as clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. My support is based upon observations formed as a state legislator and as a practicing attorney.
As an attorney who has had recent cases pending in the Montana Supreme Court, I can state with confidence that Bowen has brought good skills to the office, resulting in competent and responsive service.
Supreme Court practitioners know that Bowen is responsive: he’s fast and thorough with the answer to every question. When the Supreme Court schedules oral argument in cases, Bowen goes above and beyond to help attorneys on the logistical questions in advance of hearings.
For the benefit of both the public and practitioners, Bowen started several major initiatives to help make the justice system more transparent to the people. He emails a report of the court’s opinions to anyone in Montana who wants to keep updated. He keeps a list of cases in the news on the website, so people can easily look up cases they may have read about.
As a legislator focused on state budget issues, I have been pleased that Mr. Greenwood has held the line on the expenditures required to run his office.
Bowen Greenwood has done an excellent job as clerk of the Montana Supreme Court. Montanans should want to keep him in the role.
Bill Mercer,
Billings
Letter to the editor: Dan Wilson for Associate Justice
Like most of my friends, I’m tired of the negativity constantly swirling around us every day — especially in the political arena. That’s why it is so refreshing to see and read about a candidate who takes the high road and runs his campaign focusing on policies rather than personalities.
Such a man is Dan Wilson. Dan has successfully served our communities as a district judge for several years and now is a candidate for Associate Justice of the Montana Supreme Court.
I’ve known Dan for many years and have found him to be an honest man, one who is a good listener, has a wealth of legal knowledge, and a man with integrity. As an Associate Judge, I believe these qualities, plus his thoroughness, attention to detail, and relentless work ethic will not only make him an asset to our state court, but will enable him to adjudicate the many challenging cases with fairness, and an adherence to the rule of law of our state and our Constitution.
Let’s help keep our Montana Supreme Court where people are heard and a place where progress and common sense can work together to showcase the Montana values we all share.
Please vote for Dan Wilson for Associate Justice of the Montana Supreme Court.
Nancy Ross,
Kalispell
Letter to the editor: BLM prioritizing health of our wild spaces
Like most Montanans, I take the health and management of our public lands very seriously. That’s why when the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) finally released its Public Lands Rule last week, I knew I could breathe a bit easier about our public lands management. I saw Tracy Stone-Manning, the Director of the BLM, speak in Missoula a few weeks ago and was encouraged by her message about her love of Montana's public lands and the need for updated management practices.
The Public Lands Rule would require the BLM to consider conservation, outdoor recreation, intact landscapes, wildlife habitat and restoration as equally important as traditional extractive activities in its multiple-use management. This is critical as our management of public lands requires flexibility to take into account the effects of climate change and to prioritize landscape health when deciding the range of public land usage.
With the threats to our public lands piling up seemingly every day, it is heartening to know that the BLM, the largest public lands manager in the nation, is prioritizing the health of our wild spaces and considering all options available to them to keep our public lands thriving.
Allison Wilson,
Missoula
Letter to the editor: Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
I am writing this letter in support of the reelection of Rep. David Bedey for House District 86. David is one of the best legislators I have met. I first met Rep. Bedey a few sessions ago as we were on opposite sides of a veteran bill he was sponsoring. Although he met resistance to his bill, he was not deterred. Many legislators would charge forward and push their bill without any regard to opposing views. Not Rep. Bedey. He engaged anyone and everyone he could to hear their concerns and work to address them. His unbiased efforts led to the passage of significant veteran legislation in support of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran who has worked with legislators for over four decades to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that Rep. David Bedey was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
David’s expertise and genuine concern for his constituents is not limited to veteran issues. I watched him work tirelessly, researching the issues, asking questions of those around him and making decisions based upon the best information he could find. That is the kind of legislator that must be returned to Helena to support the constituents of House District 86.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
Letter to the editor: Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
Bedey has genuine concern for constituents
I am writing this letter in support of the reelection of Rep. David Bedey for House District 86. David is one of the best legislators I have met. I first met Rep. Bedey a few sessions ago as we were on opposite sides of a veteran bill he was sponsoring. Although he met resistance to his bill, he was not deterred. Many legislators would charge forward and push their bill without any regard to opposing views. Not Rep. Bedey. He engaged anyone and everyone he could to hear their concerns and work to address them. His unbiased efforts led to the passage of significant veteran legislation in support of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran who has worked with legislators for over four decades to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that Rep. David Bedey was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
David’s expertise and genuine concern for his constituents is not limited to veteran issues. I watched him work tirelessly, researching the issues, asking questions of those around him and making decisions based upon the best information he could find. That is the kind of legislator that must be returned to Helena to support the constituents of House District 86.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
BLM prioritizing health of our wild spaces
Like most Montanans, I take the health and management of our public lands very seriously. That’s why when the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) finally released its Public Lands Rule last week, I knew I could breathe a bit easier about our public lands management. I saw Tracy Stone-Manning, the Director of the BLM, speak in Missoula a few weeks ago and was encouraged by her message about her love of Montana’s public lands and the need for updated management practices.
The Public Lands Rule would require the BLM to consider conservation, outdoor recreation, intact landscapes, wildlife habitat and restoration as equally important as traditional extractive activities in its multiple-use management. This is critical as our management of public lands requires flexibility to take into account the effects of climate change and to prioritize landscape health when deciding the range of public land usage.
With the threats to our public lands piling up seemingly every day, it is heartening to know that the BLM, the largest public lands manager in the nation, is prioritizing the health of our wild spaces and considering all options available to them to keep our public lands thriving.
Allison Wilson,
Missoula
Letter to the editor: Weeds
You can PULL ‘em,
And then CULL ‘em.
You can SPRAY ‘em,
Which will SLAY ‘em.
You can MOW ‘em,
Or you can HOE ‘em!
Just PLEASE, PLEASE,
Do what will SLOW ‘em!
Jane Lambert,
Stevensville, former Ravalli County Weed Board member
Letter to the editor: Choice for SD44 is easy - Wayne Rusk
Wayne Rusk is a candidate I wish each of you knew personally. I am proud to call him a friend after knowing him several years.
Wayne is representing us now in the Montana Legislature, in House District 88. He proved himself to be a solid conservative this past session and took tough votes that he knew people could question but took them because it was the right thing to do. Looking at a yes or no vote does not tell the whole story. He is happy to answer any questions on the votes he took.
Wayne is running for Senate District 44 and so will still be representing us here in Florence and Stevensville plus the House district south of Stevensville. I just read a letter by a Matthew Sullivan in the 4/17 Star. In it he states that Rusk is running to ‘get back at’ Manzella. First of all, with all of the things a candidate for office goes through, I have NEVER heard Mr. Rusk give any indication he is undertaking this huge task to ‘get back’ at anyone! Wayne is a very principled man who has worked diligently to serve the people of Florence, Stevensville and the State of Montana and Wayne has found common ground where others weren’t even looking and he has done so without compromising his core principles.
Wayne, and his family, are sacrificing a lot to enter this race because he believes the people deserve a choice. We can vote for the incumbent who represents the John Birch Society and who sadly chooses to use every negative trick and untruth in the book to win an election or we can vote for Wayne Rusk — a true conservative, whose optimism and hard work have earned him great respect with his fellow legislators.
As a former legislator here in the valley, I am very proud to endorse Wayne Rusk for SD44.
RUSK or Manzella……pretty darned easy choice!
Sharon Greef,
Former HD88 Representative
Letter to the editor: Sheehy not fit for U.S. Senate
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
Tim Sheehy’s Senate campaign received a shot in the arm recently or was it years ago? As a highly trained Navy Seal in Afghanistan he took a hit for his buddies by withholding information about a bullet in his arm. Three years after discharge, he further protected his buddies by shooting himself in the arm while falling in an injury that resulted in a $525 fine for illegally discharging a firearm in a National Park. The guy is obviously a victim of medical theft as he is now short one bullet in his arm? The park ranger looked, it was not in his gun!
Sounds like real old-time Montana values at work. While traveling in possession of properly locked and loaded firearm, in a dangerous wilderness Montana park with wild tourists all around, he shoots his arm while in the parking lot. His cover story firmly places his foot in his mouth. Let’s hope he is not presently armed and further takes aim at his foot.
What a statement of military character. He’ll fight for abortion bans and preserve Montana billionaires tax breaks. Let’s run him for the U.S. Senate!
I think I’d rather vote for a Big Sandy farmer (pun intended).
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
Letter to the editor: Wayne Rusk wants to do what's best for Montana
I am writing this letter in support of Wayne Rusk and his candidacy for Senate District 44. I had the honor of working with Wayne during the 2023, 68th Legislative Session and was pleased to find him as a thoughtful and honest legislator. It was my observation that he was very respectful of his constituency and wanted to do what was best for Montana.
I have advocated for military and Montana veteran issues at the state legislature for over 40 years. While Wayne never served, he had a solid commitment to understand our issues, ask probing questions, and make his decisions based on the facts. I was pleased to discover that Wayne Rusk, without fail, was a solid supporter of our Montana Veterans and our National Guard.
I am a 38-year veteran of the U.S. Air Force/Montana National Guard and a former State Representative who has worked with legislators to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. The 2023 Session was a particularly brisk session for our veteran and military issues. I tracked dozens of bills in committee and assessed the vote of multiple legislators. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that your Representative, Wayne Rusk, was 100% in voting for our Montana Veterans and military members.
It is because of his solid record with our veterans and National Guard members, I ask you to support the election of Wayne Rusk Senate District 44.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
Letter to the editor: Property Tax Assistance Program
With discussions with the governor, the filing application deadline for the property tax assistance program has been extended until June 1. This program can help citizens on a fixed or limited income by reducing the tax rate on their home.
To be eligible, there are three important facts:
- You must own or currently be under contract to purchase a home or mobile/manufactured home.
- You must live in the home as a primary residence for a least seven months of the year.
- You must have a 2022 Federal Adjusted Gross Income, excluding capital and income losses less than: *single $27,621 or *married or head of household $37,019.
The assistance level can be from a 30% to 80% reduction of the normal tax rate. To find information on your status, contact your local State Department of Revenue office or call the state office in Helena at 406-444-6900.
Rep. Denley M. Loge,
St. Regis
Letter to the editor: Sharyl Allen is committed to our children's education
Today, I stand with great pride to endorse Sharyl Allen for Superintendent of Public Instruction, a leader whose commitment to our children's education reflects Montana's spirit of resilience and community.
Sharyl has consistently demonstrated an innovative approach to education, addressing urgent challenges with swift and thoughtful actions that drive our educational system forward. Her career, marked by a commitment to modern educational practices, showcases her readiness to face issues head-on, even under personal challenges.
Her spiritual depth and focus on family values align closely with Montana’s ethos of unity and independence. Sharyl's compassion and empathy embody the spiritual and cultural traditions of our state, advocating for every Montanan.
A lifelong educator, Sharyl’s tireless advocacy extends beyond the classroom. She works relentlessly to ensure that every student, teacher, and district has the support needed to unlock potential and achieve success.
In challenging times, Sharyl has proven her ability to uphold our values and confront significant issues directly. Education — the cornerstone of our children's future — is facing critical threats from various external pressures, including societal challenges that undermine our foundational values. Sharyl stands ready to lead our educational system through these trials with unwavering dedication.
I urge you to support Sharyl Allen for Superintendent of Public Instruction. A vote for Sharyl is a vote for a leader who embodies the very best of Montana — innovation, integrity, and a deep commitment to the future of our children.
Let's unite behind her to secure a bright, enduring future for all Montanan children.
Robert Hoffman,
Helena
Letter to the editor: Binkley is a staunch supporter of our veterans
- Roger Hagan, Great Falls
I am writing this letter in support of Representative Michele Binkley and her candidacy for House District 85. As a 40 plus year advocate at the State Legislature for Montana veteran and military interests, I can affirm without concern, that Rep. Binkley is a staunch supporter of our Montana veterans.
I am a 38-year veteran of the U.S. Air Force/Montana National Guard and a former state representative who has worked with legislators to encourage their understanding and support of the needs of our veterans. In the past four years I have had the opportunity to work with Michele and I have found her to be truly engaged in seeking knowledge of our military and veteran issues. She is deliberate in her consideration of our efforts, asks questions about our concerns, and seeks to reach a reasoned solution.
The 2023 68th Legislative Session was a particularly brisk session for our veterans and military members. I tracked dozens of bills in committee and assessed the vote of multiple legislators. In the 33 bills that I used as my measuring stick, I am pleased to report that your representative, Michele Binkley, was 100% in voting for our Montana veterans and military members.
It is because of her stellar record with our veterans, I ask you to support the re-election of Rep. Michele Binkley for House District 85.
Roger Hagan,
Great Falls
Letter to the editor: Vote for Monica Tranel
- Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf, Corvallis
The Ricketts Road one million dollar repair check is a late federal Easter ham (political pork). Much needed and delayed repairs of local roads should be completed using our federal tax dollars. Let’s be honest. Ryan Zinke using his power as the lowest rated member on the House Appropriations Committee; agreed to sign a bill keeping the government open conditioned on inclusion of community projects funding. (appropriations.senate.gov/fy-2024-congressionally-directed-spending)
Zinke’s press release made no mention of his 2021 failure to vote for the American Rescue Plan and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. By comparison not signing either bill defines a three years later 2024 road repair for what it is “an election year eating of the pork with local politicians!” Where is Zinke’s cry “budget deficits are a national security threat?”
I suggest voters sack him and the horse he rode in on as past disgraced Secretary of Interior. A simple way to place the credit correctly and acknowledge his earlier equine droppings is for voters to vote for Monica Tranel in November’s election.
Archie L. Thomas and Merry Schrumpf,
Corvallis
Letter to the editor: Conspiracy?
- Mary Fahnestock-Thomas, Hamilton
Everyone’s doing it, so hey!
My theory is that Donald Trump is important to his “handlers,” including some but not all prominent Republicans, to get the votes and win the presidency, and then Project 2025 will take over while he follows his own personal agenda pretty much on the sidelines.
Not familiar with Project 2025 (officially the Presidential Transition Project)? What I have read looks more like trying to sound good than concrete steps to a workable government, but it certainly is right-wing. Wikipedia offers a summary and background (and no, Wikipedia is not just for high-schoolers trying to write essays on time, says this PhD).
The thing is this: Trump is under increasing financial, personal and political pressure. Having put up a bond to cover the $93 million for sexually assaulting E. Jean Carroll, he was clearly struggling to come up with the $450 million he owes the state of New York for financial fraud, so he appealed and the court agreed to settle for $175 million for starters.
He did come up with that, but investigation is finding it to be pretty shaky. And his trial for mis-using campaign funds as hush-money about sexual affairs prior to the 2016 election is now underway in Manhattan, and he looks tired and angry and frazzled and is apparently tending to fall asleep in the courtroom.
Hitler was helped to power by people who figured that they would be able to work around him to realize their own political ambitions. It didn’t so much turn out that way for many of them, but in this case, because Trump’s focus is himself, not an ideology, it might work, and I think the writers and collaborators of Project 2025 are counting on that.
I do not trust people or organizations that appear to be single-mindedly ideological and ambitious, such as Stephen Miller, Steve Bannon, The Heritage Foundation, and so many others listed on Project 2025.
My own ideology? Kindness, and treating others the way I want to be treated.
Mary Fahnestock-Thomas,
Hamilton
Letter to the editor: Put the pressure on
- Star Jameson, Hamilton
As our rivers and creeks flow way below their banks this year, I am concerned about water shortages for crops and cattle in the heat of the summer. I hear others discussing this as well. By professional management I assume we will come through with what we need and my agricultural neighbors will not suffer setbacks. In the meantime, I need to say that a mine similar to the proposed Sheep Creek Mine used 278 million gallons of water per year for its operations. I’m not a geologist, but when I consider that kind of drain on our watershed I know it’s a threat to the whole valley’s ground water supply.
Montana has always tried to develop its resources, sometimes to the extreme. Now we’re looking at a “rare earth” economy to possibly replace our coal economy. I’m okay with that…adjustment to economic realities is the name of this era we’re in. But I do not want 500-700 foot deep holes in the summits of our beautiful Bitterroot Mountains because of a mining model which has been proven to leak hundreds of gallons of toxic water into our fisheries. There are other options, some already established. The Berkeley Pit, for example, is being tapped for the rare minerals in its waters.
We Montanans have already let down our guard with our antiquated mining laws which hundreds (really!) of now-defunct corporations have taken advantage of. (There are 8000 abandoned mines in the state currently.) In at least five instances it is you and I who are paying for site cleanup because the corporations have conveniently gone bankrupt. Do ask the candidates you want to vote for what they will do about new mining legislation, and what do they think about Sheep Creek.
I came here 50 years ago for many of the same reasons folks are coming now. Clean water (threatened), open spaces (threatened), clean air (pray that July is fire free), and neighbors that practice these same values. We need to put the pressure on the Forest Service, Fish, Wildlife and Parks, Bureau of Land Management and our local politicians. If we don’t, we stand to lose far more than we can imagine.
Star Jameson,
Hamilton
Letter to the editor: Vote against nullification
- Mike Cressler, Hamilton
In my research on the candidates for the Montana Legislature in Ravalli County, I’ve discovered to my dismay that one of the leaders of the nullification movement, Sen. Theresa Manzella, holds office in Ravalli County.
The nullification movement misinterprets the U.S. Constitution to give any state the right to nullify or invalidate, and thus ignore, any federal law that it considers unconstitutional or otherwise in violation of the Constitution. Nullification is not the law and never has been.
Nevertheless, in the last legislative session, Sen. Manzella sponsored Senate Bill 434, which was intended to give political structure and legitimacy to the nullification movement. When adopted by at least nine states, this bill would have created a political body called a “Constitution Settlement Commission of the States,” whose purpose would have been to define what powers the states have “granted” to the federal government in the U.S. Constitution.
If enacted, the bill would allow the participating states through this commission to issue decisions, like a court, on whether a particular federal law is constitutional or not and, if not, recommend that the federal law be ignored. This is nullification — pure and simple.
Fortunately, the Montana Senate recognized this nullification bill for what it was and voted it down with only about a half dozen voting for it. But we cannot give Sen. Manzella another chance to introduce this radically un-American bill again or anything like it. Vote for Wayne Rusk!
Mike Cressler,
Hamilton
Letter to the editor: Our courts have final say
Don Kaltschmidt’s April 13 attack on Montana’s courts and judges, while predictable for a state Republican Party chairman, reflects woeful ignorance of, and perhaps even contempt for, the U.S. and Montana constitutions.
Our courts, not legislatures, governors, attorneys general, and certainly not partisan political party chairs, thankfully have the final say in interpreting and applying these laws to protect individual rights and freedoms.
Montana’s Constitution ranks among our country’s best in enshrining, defining, and shielding these rights from partisan political meddling or worse. I may personally disagree with some constitutional court case decisions, but I never question their legitimacy or the power of our judges to make them because I do not want my rights messed with by political hacks.
Legislatures have their legitimate place in our government system, as I know well from my law faculty Advanced Legislation course experiences seeing UM students draft some 130 bills enacted as current Montana statutes. I respect what legislatures do, but recognize their lawmaking powers cease when used to violate our individual constitutional rights.
Regrettably, Montana sees this far too often because a majority of our legislators seem clueless about what they can and cannot legally do. The solution to Kaltschmidt’s concern requires him to show actual, not fake, leadership by urging his fellow Republicans in the Montana Legislature to stop passing so many unconstitutional laws and then blaming judges who do their jobs in striking them down.
If he can’t or won’t do this, he should stick to selling cars.
David Aronofsky,
Missoula
Letter to the editor: We must make sure democracy survives
Just over six months left.
That is the short time left before what promises to be one of the most, if not the most, consequential elections ever faced by our democracy. Are you ready? Did you realize that candidate filing deadlines have already come and gone in Montana? Thus, our choices among candidates running for election have already narrowed. Next, the primaries will take place in less than two months, reducing our choices even more.
At that point, in many cases we are already faced with making a choice among the proverbial “lesser of evils.”
The question is: “Will Democracy survive?” Who has the answer? We do. As voters, we must help make sure our democracy survives.
Don’t think there’s any real threat? Look around. Investigate the actions and votes of those politicians who represent you. Don’t forget to explore every aspect of your national, state, and local candidates’ records and promises. Are they likely to work for you and all of Montana or primarily focused on maintaining their own powers? If one or more has been most interested in the latter, fire them.
Even if that means choosing the “lesser of evils,” say "you’re fired” and start right away finding new political leaders who will work for you and not just themselves. Recognize that, more than ever, our democracy’s survival depends on the success of our effort.
Galen McKibben,
Helena
Letter to the editor: Tim Sheehy's bad week
It's been a bad week for novice Republican Senate candidate Tim Sheehy. You'll recall that the two pillars of his campaign are his military service and his success as a businessman. Both took a hit this week. First, it came out that Mr. Sheehy either lied to the Park Service about a purported gunshot incident at Logan Pass that may, or may not, have led to a wound; or lied to his superiors in the military about a wound he received, but didn't report, in Afghanistan. Or maybe he did shoot himself in Glacier and is lying about it on the campaign to make it appear its a combat wound. In any case, it shows he's pretty loose with the truth, to put it mildly. Then the second shoe drops— it is reported that his Bozeman based company lost $77 million dollars last year. And that it may end up shutting down due to these losses, and/or his campaign for Senate. So much for the "successful business man" schtick. And oh yes, what about those employees who may then lose their jobs and security? Of course, we know that in this MAGA era, the truth doesn't matter, and a business fraud can become president. Montanans would be wise to choose the tried and true, John Tester, for Senate, he's as straight a shooter.
Kim Wilson,
Helena
More like this...
'; oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append(sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } }); } // Build engagement set $.each(oResponse.assets, function(index) { if (index == 1 && sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == null) { sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = oResponse.assets[0].id; } // Display assets once origin is found // Find origin then begin displaying assets if (bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { if (this.id == sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Found orgin a second time. Stop gathering assets and kill next_url bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = null; oEngagementMore_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.remove(); } else if (bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false && this.id != '69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37') { // Display asset var sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = ''; if (this.content.includes('engagement-asset') && iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 < iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 ++; sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 += '
' + this.content + '
'; } } } else { if (this.id == sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Origin found. Begin displaying assets bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; } else { // Origin found is false. Skip asset // Fail-safe in case origin is not present in set. This can be removed when origin is fixed. if (bFirstRun_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { // Stored first id sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = this.id; bFirstRun_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = false; } else if (this.id == sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // We've started again. Force origin sOriginID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = sFirstID_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37; bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; } // end Fail-safe } } // Append engagement assets to container oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append(sHTML_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); // Stop traversing asset array if (iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 >= iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = true; return false; } }); // Include block_id on newly added list items oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.find('.engagement-item.original').each(function() { var sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = scrubURL($(this).find("a.centered-content-link").attr("href")); if(sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37!="javascript:void(0)"){ // Add content discovery tracking sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 += '#tncms-source=endcard-gallery'; // Add to image and headlines links $(this).removeClass('original').find("a.centered-content-link").attr("href", sHref_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } }); // Check next URL if (sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 && bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false) { // if origin hasn't been found yet and we hit next_url. Trigger the set to pull in again. if (bFoundOrigin_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == false) { // No origin yet. Call the populate function __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); } else { // Append sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 to engagement set oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.append('
'); if (iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 < iMaxDisplay_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37) { // Get next url and request more assets __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(oEngagementMore_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.data('next-url')); } } } // Add total count to container if (bStop_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 == true) { // Add total count to container oEngagementContainer_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.attr("data-engagement-total", iDisplayCount_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); // Remove engagement loading spinner oEngagementSpinner_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37.remove(); return false; } } else { // Empty asset set returned. Go back in for a real set if(__tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].attempts<2){ if(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37==null||sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37==""){ sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37 = "/news/local/hamilton-speaks-up-recently-published-letters-to-the-editor/collection_69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37.html"; } __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].populate(sNextUrl_69ad433b_44fb_5b9f_ac04_381b72c94d37); __tnt.engagement.assets["69ad433b-44fb-5b9f-ac04-381b72c94d37"].attempts++; } } }); } } // Rewrite URL for preview // TODO move to one location function scrubURL(sURL) { if (typeof sURL != 'undefined'){ return sURL; } }
Tags
- Letters
- Wire
- Dcc
'); var s = document.createElement('script'); s.setAttribute('src', 'https://assets.revcontent.com/master/delivery.js'); document.body.appendChild(s); window.removeEventListener('scroll', throttledRevContent); __tnt.log('Load Rev Content'); } } }, 100); window.addEventListener('scroll', throttledRevContent); }
