One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (2024)

By Rei Penber

Despite all the build up, Yamato ended up not joining the Straw Hat Pirates and here's why.

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (1)

The Straw Hat Pirates are a powerful bunch that hail from the East Blue and are led by the protagonist of One Piece, Monkey D. Luffy. Although the beginnings of this crew were certainly humble, they have now become one of the strongest forces on the seas of the One Piece world. Over the years, Luffy has recruited some of the most talented people, such as Zoro who aims to become the world's strongest swordsman, and others with similar ambitions.

RELATED: Strong Anime Characters Who Don't Really Know How To Fight

After the two-year time skip, the crew is more powerful than ever, and recently, they added Jinbe, one of the former Shichibukai, to their ranks. In the Wano country arc, the Straw Hats could potentially have added another member to the crew in Yamato, who calls himself Kaido's son. Initially all set on leaving Onigashima, Yamato decided to stay behind in Wano at the end of the arc. This decision, although abrupt on the surface, has several reasons for it.

Yamato's Decision

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (2)

Being born as Kaido's child, it was a given that Yamato would endure a difficult life. However, when he started to idolize Kozuki Oden after witnessing the Hour of the Legends in the Flower Capital, Yamato's life became hellish. At merely 8 years of age, Yamato was chained by Kaido and prevented from leaving Onigashima. For 20 years, Yamato was forced to stay on the island despite him wanting to explore the world and live a life as free as Oden once did. His shackles kept him from not just making friends but also from saving those that he loved.

Ace, Yamato's only friend once, died in the Paramount War, and despite knowing that, Yamato could not aid him. Years later, however, Luffy finally arrived on Onigashima and freed him from his shackles. For the first time, he was free to follow his heart and set out to sea. Furthermore, Kaido's defeat meant that Yamato was now free to join the Straw Hat Pirates. In fact, Yamato openly declared that he would join Luffy on several occasions, however, in the end, he changed his mind. Yamato decided to stay back in Wano simply because Oden started his journey by going from region to region in Wano as well. Yamato still idolizes Oden and wants to follow in his footsteps. As such, he decided to explore Wano first and then set out to sea at a later time.

RELATED: One Piece: Things You Should Know About Admiral Green Bull

The Strength Of The Crew

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (3)

While Yamato wanting to explore Wano first was the main reason for him staying behind, there is certainly more as to why he couldn't join the crew just yet. For the Straw Hat Pirates, Oda has always maintained the Monster Trio, which includes Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji, to be the strongest fighters. When Jinbe appeared to be stronger than both Zoro and Sanji, Oda had him wait to join the crew until the point where the two had already surpassed him arrived. In the war of Onigashima, it was quite clear that Yamato was stronger than both Zoro and Sanji. Yamato was revealed to be a master of advanced Conqueror's Haki and could even fight Kaido in a one-on-one battle for an extended period of time.

Furthermore, his Mythical Zoan Devil Fruit gave him even more durability and stamina to fight dragged-out battles. Undoubtedly, Yamato would have been second to only Luffy in strength had he joined the crew after Wano. As such, the Monster Trio dynamic would certainly have been disturbed as well. To avoid that, Oda simply made Yamato wait just like Jinbe once did. It will take quite a while for Luffy's Wings to surpass Yamato, however, once they do, his chances of joining up with them would certainly increase.

What The Future Holds For Yamato

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (4)

While Yamato did decide to stay back in Wano, that's not to say that he can never be a part of the Straw Hat Pirates ever. After all, Yamato did mention that he would set out to sea once he finishes journeying across all of Wano. At the same time, Luffy also told Yamato, Kin'emon, and Momonosuke that they are free to join him when they feel like they are ready to be pirates. Luffy warned them that his crew doesn't take weaklings and Yamato certainly isn't one. His relationship with the crew is absolutely incredible and once he journeys across the land, he could certainly join up with Luffy and the gang again.

For the time being, Yamato certainly will not appear in One Piece. The Straw Hats are likely to explore the rest of the New World first and then try to locate the last Road Poneglyph. After that, Yamato's chances of joining the Straw Hat Pirates certainly increase. This is because a war with the World Government will inevitably be fought and Wano will certainly be involved in it. This would be the perfect opportunity for Yamato to become the last crew member. At the same time, he would definitely want to join Luffy because at the end of Oden's journey was Laugh Tale. To tread the same path as Oden would mean to go to Laugh Tale as well and Yamato's only chance of doing that would be with Luffy. As such, it is almost a given that, in the future, Yamato will join up with the Straw Hat Pirates and become a member of the crew. For now, however, he is focusing on traveling across Wano.

MORE: One Piece: Devil Fruits That Still Haven't Been Introduced In The Series

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained (2024)

FAQs

One Piece: Why Yamato Didn't Join The Straw Hat Pirates, Explained? ›

Yamato did not join the Straw Hats because she is very strong. Oda wants to focus on developing the main Straw Hats rather than the new Yamato, which is more than enough revealed in the Wano arc. In the end, Yamato was able to face Kaido head-on, without any support, in a one-on-one battle.

Why did Yamato not join the Straw Hats? ›

The reason that Oda had Yamato stay back despite spending the entire 3rd act talking about how she was going to join the Straw Hats is because she's too strong for now. This is the same thing that happened to Jinbe. He was too strong during Fishman Island.

Is Yamato technically a strawhat? ›

Thus Yamato appearing in the splash page shows that even though they didn't officially join the crew at the end of Wano like many fans wanted, they are ultimately still a Straw Hat at heart.

Why did Yamato not join the crew reddit? ›

Each official member has a specific purpose that they adopt when joining the Strawhats. Yamato on the other hand offers has no real skills that would contribute to the crew. When Oden joined Roger's crew, it was partially because of his ability to decipher the poneglyphs.

What is the Yamato controversy One Piece? ›

Ever since Yamato first appeared in the Wano arc, a major point of discussion has been their gender identity, as while Yamato was assigned female at birth, they're introduced as Kaido's son and prefer to be addressed not just as male, but specifically as Kozuki Oden.

Will Yamato join Straw Hats in future? ›

Is Yamato strong enough to be a member of the Straw Hats Grand Fleet? Yamato is too strong to be a grand fleet member. If anything, the main crew would be the place for the Oni princess, since her abilities are on the monster trio level. In fact, Yamato will be a crew member in the future.

Did Luffy ask Yamato to join? ›

Luffy would approve of Yamato joining his crew. However, Admiral Ryokugyu's attack on Wano made Yamato realize that others would try the same now that Kaidou was gone, and he decided to stay in Wano to help protect it. Luffy agreed and entrusted Yamato to protect Wano for him.

Is Yamato pregnant? ›

Ace got Yamato pregnant and in order for the baby to survive Yamato has to hold the baby for 2 years and it has already been 2 years and when Luffy kills kaido she will give birth.

Who is Kaido's daughter? ›

Yamato is the daughter of Kaido. She is otherwise widely referred to as his son due to often presenting herself as a man as a result of her profound admiration for the legendary samurai Kozuki Oden and her aspiration to emulate him.

Is Yamato originally a girl? ›

It is confirmed that Yamato was born as a female biologically. Yamato was even called the Oni Princess further to confirm that. But Kaido liked to address his daughter as a son so that Yamato could take over as his heir after him. Will Yamato join Luffy?

Why Yamato failed? ›

Battleship Yamato: Failure to Engage

Yamato's poor service history is also due to the fact that the IJN was also reluctant to hazard Yamato without air cover, which limited how the vessels could be used. That also explains why the third vessel of the class was converted to a carrier while still under construction.

Who was Yamato waiting for? ›

After Ace died, Yamato waited patiently for the time that they would meet Ace's brother, Luffy so that they could join his crew, which they openly declared to Kaido that they'll be leaving out to the sea with them after defeating the Beast Pirates.

Did Ace and Yamato like each other? ›

During his stay in Wano, Ace also befriended Yamato, the son of Kaido. Even though they met while fighting, they quickly became friends over a few drinks when they realized how similar they truly were.

Why is Kaido's son a girl? ›

Historically, there were never any women shoguns, only men. Kaido probably wanted a son, but he got a daughter instead. Despite this, he refers to Yamato as his son. Anyone who can do their own math will understand that it obviously cannot be because of Yamato's admiration to Oden, since he was Kaido's sworn enemy.

Why does Kaido hate Yamato? ›

Due to Kaido being a tyrant who has enslaved an entire country and hurt all those close to Yamato, it is no surprise that the two find each other at opposing ends. Yamato has cut all ties with his father for good and has decided that he'll drive him out of Wano, no matter the cost.

Why does Yamato think she's a boy? ›

Yamato was probably clinging onto the identity of Oden as a coping mechanism, and is okay being called Yamato but still seems to hold onto to the idea that they are male, considering they jumped in the male bath no problem.

Who is stronger Yamato or Zoro? ›

Yamato is strong enough to go toe-toe-toe with Hybrid Kaido, and will only get stronger as the manga progresses. Zoro can't tank a beating from Kaido like their child can. I think Yamato has the edge between the two, at least until the end of the current arc.

Why did Yamato stay in Wano? ›

Main Reason: Oda didnt want Yamato to join the crew that quickly and for no big reason. Jimbei officially became the new nakama in this arc and the addition of Yamato to the crew could eclipse him. Plot reason: Because Wano was too weak to defend itself from any foreign threat like the Marines or other Yonkou.

Who is stronger Luffy or Yamato? ›

His Advanced Conqueror's Haki has proven to significantly damage Kaido, who even calls their fight the first serious one he's had in a while. Without a doubt, this proves Luffy to be stronger than Yamato in the current series.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Duncan Muller

Last Updated:

Views: 6257

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (59 voted)

Reviews: 82% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Duncan Muller

Birthday: 1997-01-13

Address: Apt. 505 914 Phillip Crossroad, O'Konborough, NV 62411

Phone: +8555305800947

Job: Construction Agent

Hobby: Shopping, Table tennis, Snowboarding, Rafting, Motor sports, Homebrewing, Taxidermy

Introduction: My name is Duncan Muller, I am a enchanting, good, gentle, modern, tasty, nice, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.