The Shocking Truth About Carbon Credits (2024)

Every day, companies around the world are emitting massive amounts of carbon into the atmosphere. As we face the urgent and pressing threat of climate change, many of these companies have begun to make promises to promote more sustainable business practices that are better for the environment. While this is no easy task, many of these companies have turned to carbon credits as a solution. In fact, the carbon exchange industry was a $1 Billion Industry in 2021!

But are carbon credits really the answer to our environmental anguish, or are they simply a way for companies to circumvent real, meaningful change? Do carbon offsets give companies permission to continue bad practices, and to just buy themselves into sustainability? We’re sharing our view into the world of carbon credits, exploring both their pros and cons, and shedding a realistic perspective on these controversial tools. Join us as we uncover the reality of the carbon exchange and its impact on the fight against climate change.

What are carbon credits?

Carbon credits are a market-based exchange program set to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, in which one credit represents 1 Tonne of CO2 removed from the atmosphere. Companies or individuals can purchase these credits on carbon markets. Whether purchased directly from carbon market companies or from government-run exchanges, the credit offsets their own emissions. The idea is that companies with high emissions purchase credits from those with low emissions. This incentivizes companies to reduce their emissions and invest in or fund carbon-reducing projects. Companies or individuals can purchase carbon credits or carbon offsets from platforms such as Aspiration, TerraPass, or ClimateTrade . These platforms offer ways to invest in projects that promote bio-diversity, fund renewable energy projects, or fund sustainable farming projects around the globe. Carbon offsets are very affordable, ranging from a few dollars really with limitless potential.

Carbon credits are often touted as a way for businesses to take action on climate change and reduce their carbon footprint. For some companies, they may be a necessary part of a larger sustainability plan. For others, purchasing credits may be a way to satisfy customers or investors who are demanding more eco-friendly practices. However, it’s important to note that carbon credits are not a magic solution to climate change. They are just one tool in a larger toolkit for reducing emissions. Carbon offsets should not be seen as a substitute for real action to reduce emissions at the source. In fact, many companies have been criticized for overusing the program in their sustainability plan, including Chevron, AirFrance, and Disney.

But it’s important to understand some of the pros of the carbon market and explore its potential for reducing emissions and fighting climate change.

Pros of carbon credits

Carbon credits can offer several benefits for businesses or individuals looking to reduce their carbon footprint. They provide a way for companies to offset their unavoidable emissions. A few examples include manufacturing assets that cannot be readily converted to renewable energy or airplanes or transportation that cannot readily use biofuel. This allows businesses to take accountability for their environmental impact and work towards being more sustainable.

Secondly, carbon credits can be an attractive option for companies looking to enhance their reputation as eco-friendly. By investing in carbon credits, businesses can showcase their commitment to reducing emissions and demonstrate their corporate social responsibility. This can appeal to consumers who are increasingly conscious of their environmental impact and demand more sustainable options.

Finally, carbon credits can provide financial benefits for businesses. By reducing their emissions, companies may be able to secure partnerships with other eco-conscious businesses, and attract green investors. Additionally, some governments offer incentives and tax breaks for companies that invest in carbon credits. This stimulates the greater environmental movement and encourages better environmental practices by other businesses in their industry.

Carbon markets are also good for those on the receiving end. It also provides a platform for businesses and consumers to fund projects that directly benefit the environment. A few examples found on CarbonTrade include funding for hydropower in China and a wind farm in Argentina. Commonly, many carbon-offset projects include planting trees and reforestation.

While carbon credits are not a perfect solution, they can be a useful tool in a wider sustainability plan. However, it’s important to consider the potential drawbacks and limitations of carbon credits as well.

But we’re exploring the truth here today, so we need to understand the downsides. Carbon markets have limitations in reducing emissions and fighting climate change.

Cons of carbon credits

Carbon credits have gained popularity as an easy way for businesses to offset their carbon emissions. However, there are some cons that cannot be overlooked. One major concern is the potential for carbon credits to merely become a way for companies to continue emitting greenhouse gases without making any real effort to reduce their carbon footprint. Additionally, there is little oversight or regulation in the carbon credit market. This raises questions about the legitimacy of some credits and the effectiveness of the market as a whole.

Another potential issue with carbon markets is the lack of transparency in how they are created and tracked. It can be difficult for businesses to know exactly where their money is going, and if it is truly making an impact on carbon reduction.

For example, a popular method of carbon offsets includes planting trees. However, but a tree may take over 50 years for to reach its carbon sequestering potential. And along that time, there is limited consensus on how much carbon a single tree can capture. For example, in a quick Google search for carbon offsets with trees, I found that one credit can equal anywhere from one tree to twenty trees!

The lack of regulation is the biggest area of concern with carbon credits. For a consumer or a company, it can be difficult to measure your exact impact. Especially if the proposed offset will make a difference in a realistic timeframe.

The truth about carbon credits

While carbon credits have gained popularity in recent years as a way for businesses to offset their carbon emissions, they are not without limitations. One major issue is the lack of transparency in how carbon credits are created and tracked. This lack of transparency makes it difficult for businesses to know exactly where their money is going and if it is truly making an impact on reducing carbon emissions. It is important to recognize these limitations and potential drawbacks when considering the effectiveness of carbon credits. While they can be a helpful tool in the fight against climate change, it is crucial to take a critical look at how they are being implemented and assess whether they are truly making a difference.

Carbon credits can play a role in reducing our carbon footprint, but we must be aware of their limitations. As individuals, businesses, and communities, we must continue to explore new and innovative ways to combat climate change, and work towards a more sustainable future. As consumers, it’s up to us to push for real change from companies and demand long-term solutions. Let’s use our voices and our wallets to make a difference. Remember, the shocking truth about carbon credits is that they’re not the complete answer to the climate crisis. Be sure to subscribe to Made to Sustain for more information content around climate impact!

Thanks for stopping by to read our post!

Related