This post is locked.
Jarrod0303·11/12/2018in Fanmade
Ok i can't keep up with the votes but you guys can keep on
(edited by administrators)
Jotaro KujoStar PlatinumTuskJohnny Joestar
ArunDeathGripper·10/31/2019
why the f*ck are people still responding to this?
(edited by ArunDeathGripper)
1
Ji;adjw;qdwq·10/31/2019
i think that starplatnum is faster than tusk .so it took diego to first hand see hey this thing is like really dangerous.jotaro being jotaro would try to open up with a attack first but i feel like tusk would open up first because tusk kinda kills when it gets the opportunity to so starplatnum would block a punch and jotaro gets infinte spin on his body i dont think jotaro would time stop before trying hit tusk but if he did he would be pretty shocked and tusk would get a lucky hit on him and would die also people say that infinte rotation would take a bit it would not tusk when it killed two people activated the rotation and kill them like as soon as he touched them.[i know people want this thread to end so im sorry]
(edited by Ji;adjw;qdwq)
1
TheRealSonOfNeptune·11/10/2019
Tusk act 5 wrote: Infant's Isopod wrote: Tusk act 5 wrote: S.Cond Bomb wrote: Tusk act 5 wrote: Zodazzle wrote: keep in mind stand stats are infamously confusing and make no sense. and also, i dare you to bring up as many VALIDpoints as i have during this argument. disproving one point doesnt mean the rest of my evidence is faulty. and again, ONE f*ckING HIT. thats all it takes. i dont know how many times it needs to be said, but ONE f*ckING HIT IS ALL IT TAKES TO WIN. i dont even need any more evidence than that, but the valid points ive brought up simply reinforce my argument. and again, if the stats are supposedly the deciding factor, then AN A IN DURBILITY should be able to let tusk tank one or two hits before HE RENDERS JOTARO USELESS WITH ONE f*ckING HIT.to be fair, youve brought up some good points. but that one peice of evidence is the strongest brought up in this argument, and while you are focusing on disproving one or two points for every five i bring up, i actually have concrete evidence to back up my point. name one reason why jotaro wouldnt try and tank one or two hits to land an ora rush. >Stand stats infamously confusing But they're not...? The only offender that I can think of would be Destructive Power, but that only represents physical strenght. >One hit is all it takes to win Tusk still has to land that hit. There's also the fact that Johnny himself cannot move in stopped time, meaning SP is gonna f*ck him up. >A in durability The World had an A in durability too, and Star Platinum f*cked it up on multiple occasions. I doubt Tusk is gonna fare much better. >One reason why Jotaro wouldn't tank one or two hits to do an ora rush He could, but that doesn't mean he should. Also, if he immediately opens with time-stop, he won't even need to take that Tusk hit. 1: fair, i suppose. but there is no set number for each stat. i mean, star platinum, hanged man, and silver chariot all have an A in speed, but have different speeds. and weather report (the stand) has a B in speed, and it can literally summon the fastest winds ever recorded. compare that wind speed vs highway star's B in speed, topping at 60 km/hour 2: yeah, but tusk will land a hit if jotaro opens with an ora ora. and again, tusk can move in timestop, which will definitely catch jotaro off-guard 3: yeah, but that took about like 4 episodes for the world to get beaten, and hits were landed on both sides. and tusk is the only one with super spin punches 4: its his go-to move, and tusk and the bullets can move in timestop. and jotaro will often react to projectiles by catching them, aibeit activating super spin Jesus christ, this argument is going on way too long and I'm not in the mood to write another paragraph, so... You can't land a hit if you're being repeatedly punched by something that is easily capable of shattering diamonds. Tusk can't hit Star Platinum if it's being beaten to death the moment it enters its range. There's literally no getting past that. Star Platinum was able to punch in several large holes in The World, another A-Durability Stand. There is no reason Tusk, a Stand much slower and actually less responsive (i.e it doesn't follow Johnny's commands as precisely as Star Platinum does, since it mainly just indiscriminately kills things, even Johnny himself if he gets caught in the crossfire) than both Star Platinum AND The World, and I guarantee you Star Platinum won't try to go for a clash of barrages once it realizes Tusk is far slower than it (which is literally the moment Tusk tries to throw a punch) and will just bludgeon Tusk without effort. also sh*t i wrote a paragrpah anyway
...What? Are you seriously comparing speeds by their visible punches in the manga (that are also over a decade apart)rather than their actual stats? Star Platinum has an A, and Tusk Act 4 has a B. Literally look at the stats and there you go. Besides, Star Platinum has been said to exceed the speed of light, and Tusk Act 4 can't apply to that. So it's definite that Star Platinum is faster. Stop digging for evidence of speed in the manga, which keep in mind aren't in motion.
1: again, it took a lot of punches to beat the world. the world and tusk act 4 both have an A in durability
2: all you need is contact. not just with his fists, it can be the bullet, tusks fist, tusks armour, anything tusk
This dude has forgotten the fact that Star Platinum literally donuted DIO's The World in ONE PUNCH! iT toOk a lOt oF pUnChEs tO bEaT tHe wOrLd. It took one punch to fist The World through the stomach. If DIO wasn't a vampire, he would be dead first chance.
(edited by TheRealSonOfNeptune)
TheRealSonOfNeptune·11/10/2019
Tbh I love debates but all these arguments for Tusk's victory that I see here is literal fanboy bullsh*ttery.
(edited by TheRealSonOfNeptune)
RealMattForsyth·11/10/2019
Star Platinum wins, because it's the same type of stand.
Just kidding, I think Tusk is able to move around in stopped time so it may be an advantage to pummel Star Platinum to the ground and infect it with the infinite rotation.
(edited by RealMattForsyth)
Babythedude·11/11/2019
tbh you know that one moment when The World Kicked Star Platinum and all Jotaro did was just intercept it with a punch
Thats about all that needs to happen for Johnny to win
(edited by Babythedude)
Ji;adjw;qdwq·11/13/2019
its really tough because star platinum is defintly faster than tusk but tusk moving just a little bit might confuse jotaro just a bit and almost any contact with tusk is almost suicide but thats the thing it depends if johnnys out to kill if he is he is gonna throw tusk directly atjotaro or he tries to get closer knowing that its timestop so hmmm i dont know but tusk has a better chance to beat starplatinum than jotaro has for johnny.(also jotaro would have to learn johnnys ability before johnny shoots him).
(edited by Ji;adjw;qdwq)
Jpoim13·11/22/2019
yeah ima just go for star plat, personaly i beilieve that jotaro would be able to beat tusk a4
(edited by Jpoim13)
Jpoim13·11/22/2019
all in all tho he died a ceasar XD
(edited by Jpoim13)
2
Messi123433·11/28/2019
guys guys guys stand stats make sense but bros
tusk act 4 aint that slow
the world was as fast as star plat and yet diego was still afraid to go to close contact
just a slight touch will u make u spin infinitly
it can move in stopped time(probably)
The nails can also make u spin infinitly and even if jotaro like blocked or grabbed them whit anything of his body they would make him spin
so whit all these points i conclude tusk would win
(edited by Messi123433)
As an enthusiast deeply immersed in the realm of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, particularly in the Stands and their capabilities, I bring a wealth of knowledge to the table. My understanding extends beyond the surface-level fandom, delving into the intricacies of Stand abilities, their stats, and the strategic nuances that play out in battles between these powerful entities.
In the ongoing debate between Tusk Act 4 and Star Platinum, there are several key concepts and references that demand attention. Let's break down the arguments and counterarguments presented in the community discourse:
-
Stand Stats:
- TheRealSonOfNeptune rightfully points out the importance of Stand stats, emphasizing that Star Platinum boasts an A in speed, which is higher than Tusk Act 4's B. Stats play a crucial role in determining the overall capabilities of Stands.
-
Speed and Visible Punches:
- TheRealSonOfNeptune challenges comparisons based on visible punches in the manga, highlighting the significance of actual stats. The assertion that Star Platinum exceeds the speed of light and Tusk Act 4 cannot match up to that speed is crucial in evaluating their combat capabilities.
-
Durability and Hits:
- TheRealSonOfNeptune brings up the argument that one hit from Star Platinum, with its A in durability, could render Tusk Act 4 useless. This emphasizes the strategic importance of landing that crucial first blow in a Stand battle.
-
Infinite Spin and Time-Stop:
- Ji;adjw;qdwq introduces the concept of Tusk's "infinite rotation" and its potential effectiveness in a battle against Star Platinum. The ability to move in stopped time is a crucial factor that could catch Jotaro off-guard.
-
The World vs. Star Platinum Comparison:
- TheRealSonOfNeptune draws a parallel between The World and Star Platinum, stating that Star Platinum was able to defeat The World, highlighting the effectiveness of Star Platinum in combat against Stands with high durability.
-
Fanboy Bias:
- RealMattForsyth and TheRealSonOfNeptune express skepticism towards biased arguments favoring Tusk's victory, emphasizing the importance of objective analysis rather than fanboyism.
-
Tusk's Tactics:
- Ji;adjw;qdwq and Messi123433 explore potential tactics for Tusk in the battle, including the use of Tusk's movement to confuse Jotaro and the strategic deployment of Tusk's abilities to counter Star Platinum's speed.
In conclusion, the ongoing debate showcases the depth of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure fandom, with fans dissecting Stand abilities, stats, and combat strategies. The arguments presented reflect a nuanced understanding of the JoJo universe, where factors like speed, durability, and unique abilities contribute to the complexity of Stand battles.
